Baseball Toaster was unplugged on February 4, 2009.
Miguel Cabrera re-signed with the slash-and-burn Marlins today for the lowly sum of $472K. Four hundred and seventy-two?
What, they couldn't spring for the extra $28K to make it an even half-million?
And they had the gall to add a provision should he find himself in the minors this year. If that should happen, Cabrera will make $296K. The man hit 33 home runs each of the last two seasons, and they couldn't guarantee the $176K difference? That wouldn't pay the weekly liquor bill for Jeffrey Loria's suite at Joe Dolphin Player Stadium-agig.
Besides what series of events could occur to drive Cabrera off the major-league roster? The Marlins have basically a Triple-A lineup going into 2006. Cabrera's the only guaranteed starting position player with any experience. Retreads Pokey Reese and Wes Helms have plenty of experience but will be battling rookies for playing time. Cabrera could pull a Glenn Davis this season and the Marlins would still be hard-pressed to replace him.
That aside, the Marlins have now signed all of their players for 2006. Now we can complete the payroll calculations that I started investing as the Marlins cut veterans (here and here).
I originally estimated Cabrera and Willis would get $5 M each, under the assumption that both were eligible for arbitration. Cabrera missed the cut for arbitrationhe only played 87 games in 2003. After Willis signed for $4.35M, I reset Cabrera to $3M.
Boy, was I wrong.
In any event, we now have the final numbers for the non-rookie players. It gets grimmer and grimmer each time I do this. Here is a comparison between last year's and this year's payroll:
Player | 2005 Salary | 2006 status | 2006 Salary |
Mike Lowell | $7,500,000 | Traded to Red Sox | |
Al Leiter | $7,000,000 | No longer with team | |
Luis Castillo | $5,166,667 | Traded to Twins | |
Paul Lo Duca | $4,666,667 | Traded to Mets | |
Juan Encarnacion | $4,435,000 | Free Agent | |
Carlos Delgado | $4,000,000 | Traded to Mets | |
Juan Pierre | $3,700,000 | Traded To Cubs | |
A.J. Burnett | $3,650,000 | FA;signed with Blue Jays | |
Alex Gonzalez | $3,400,000 | Free Agent | |
Jeff Conine | $3,000,000 | Free Agent | |
Guillermo Mota | $2,600,000 | Traded to Red Sox | |
Josh Beckett | $2,400,000 | Traded to Red Sox | |
Ismael Valdez | $1,500,000 | Free Agent | |
Todd Jones | $1,100,000 | FA; signed with Tigers | |
Jim Mecir | $1,100,000 | Free Agent | |
Damion Easley | $750,000 | FA; signed with D-Backs | |
John Riedling | $750,000 | FA, signed with Cards | |
Matt Perisho | $475,000 | No longer with team | |
Lenny Harris | $425,000 | FA;re-signed to minor-league contract | |
Brian Moehler | $400,000 | Free Agent; re-signed; SP | $1,500,000 |
Dontrelle Willis | $378,500 | SP | $4,350,000 |
Miguel Cabrera | $370,000 | Starting 3B (RF?) | $472,000 |
Nate Bump | $360,000 | RP | $400,000 |
Chris Aguila | $316,000 | Starting LF | $327,000 |
Matt Treanor | $316,000 | Backup C | $327,000 |
Antonio Alfonseca | $300,000 | Free Agent, option declined | |
Mike Mordecai | $425,000 | Free Agent | |
Paul Quantrill | $3,000,000 | Free Agent | |
Jason Vargas | ? | SP | $327,000 |
Randy Messenger | ? | RP | $327,000 |
Ron Villone | $1,950,000 | Traded to Yankees | |
Valerio de los Santos | ? | RP | $327,000 |
Scott Olsen | ? | SP | $327,000 |
Chris Resop | ? | RP | $327,000 |
Josh Johnson | ? | SP | $327,000 |
Robert Andino | ? | UT INF | $327,000 |
Jeremy Hermida | ? | Starting RF? | $327,000 |
Joe Dillon | ? | New 2B or UT? | $327,000 |
Josh Willingham | ? | Starting C/LF? | $327,000 |
Josh Wilson | ? | New 2B? | $327,000 |
Ryan Jorgensen | ? | Backup C? | $327,000 |
Alfredo Amezaga | $0 | New 3B? | $340,000 |
Mike Jacobs | $0 | Starting 1B (C?) | $327,000 |
Eric Reed | Starting CF? | $327,000 | |
Hanley Ramirez | $0 | Starting SS | $327,000 |
Sergio Mitre | $0 | SP | $330,000 |
Alfredo Amezaga | UT INF | $340,000 | |
Miguel Olivo | C | $400,000 | |
Joe Borowski | CL | $1,000,000 | |
Pokey Reese | Starting 2B | $800,000 | |
Wes Helms | 1B/3B | $800,000 | |
Total | $60,058,834 | $ 16,291,000 | |
Mordecai is based on 2004 | 28 | ||
Quantrill's 2005 contract was with the Yankees | |||
Villone's 2005 salary was paid by the Mariners | |||
Olivo's salary based on 2005 salary | |||
Borowski's salary was estimated | |||
Salary Lost | $61,343,334 | ||
Possible Payroll | $ 15,310,000 | ||
Decrease | $ 44,748,834 | -75% | |
Lowest possible (all lg min) | 8,175,000 |
So there you have it. The Marlins could possibly pay just under twice the league minimum payroll (that is, 25 times the league minimum, $327K, or $8.175M). And that's assuming that higher-paid players like Reese and Helms make the team. With the current crop, I estimate the payroll at $16,291,000, but that would fall to at least $15,310,000 when they get down to 25 players. The net effect would be that Florida would cut 75% of their payroll from last year.
That would put the Marlins at the fifth lowest payroll since 1995 and the lowest since the Expos and Pirates in 1998:
Yr | Team | Payroll |
1998 | Montreal Expos | $ 10,641,500 |
1997 | Pittsburgh Pirates | $ 10,771,667 |
1995 | Montreal Expos | $ 12,364,000 |
1998 | Pittsburgh Pirates | $ 15,065,000 |
2006 | Florida Marlins | $ 15,310,000 |
1996 | Montreal Expos | $ 16,264,500 |
2000 | Minnesota Twins | $ 16,519,500 |
1997 | Detroit Tigers | $ 17,272,000 |
1995 | Milwaukee Brewers | $ 17,798,825 |
1999 | Montreal Expos | $ 17,903,000 |
1995 | Pittsburgh Pirates | $ 18,355,345 |
1997 | Montreal Expos | $ 19,295,500 |
2003 | Tampa Bay Devil Rays | $ 19,630,000 |
2000 | Florida Marlins | $ 19,872,000 |
But if that's not enough, let's shift the focus back to the Cabrera low-balling. Cabrera batted .323 with 33 homers and a .947 OPS last season. I took a look at the lowest salaries doled out to players coming off of similar seasons (from 1985 players batting at least .300 with a minimum of 30 HR and a .900 OPS). Cabrera's is the fifth-lowest deal and the worst in twelve years. Here are the only men meeting the criteria who made less than one million dollars the next year:
Player | Yr | Salary | HR | BA | OPS |
Will Clark | 1988 | $ 320,000 | 35 | .308 | .951 |
Danny Tartabull | 1988 | $ 330,000 | 34 | .309 | .931 |
Rick Wilkins | 1994 | $ 350,000 | 30 | .303 | .937 |
Kirby Puckett | 1987 | $ 465,000 | 31 | .328 | .903 |
Miguel Cabrera | 2006 | $ 472,000 | 33 | .323 | .947 |
Lance Berkman | 2002 | $ 500,000 | 34 | .331 | 1.051 |
Larry Sheets | 1988 | $ 540,000 | 31 | .316 | .921 |
Mike Piazza | 1994 | $ 600,000 | 35 | .318 | .932 |
Albert Pujols | 2002 | $ 600,000 | 37 | .329 | 1.013 |
Frank Thomas | 1992 | $ 620,000 | 32 | .318 | 1.006 |
Brook Jacoby | 1988 | $ 812,500 | 32 | .300 | .928 |
Vernon Wells | 2004 | $ 870,000 | 33 | .317 | .909 |
Albert Pujols | 2003 | $ 900,000 | 34 | .314 | .955 |
When one considers that Cabrera isn't a one-year flash in the pan, that he has hit 33 home runs each of the last two seasons, the Marlins' offer is even more unbelievable. Only two players coming off consecutive thirty-homer seasons have been rewarded with less money, and they were at least 18 years ago. Only 13 have made $1.5M or less out of the 225 players who qualify:
Player | Yr | Salary | Prev HR | Prev BA | Prev OPS | HR 2yrs prior |
Ron Kittle | 1985 | $ 300,000 | 32 | .215 | .748 | 35 |
Jose Canseco | 1988 | $ 325,000 | 31 | .257 | .780 | 33 |
Miguel Cabrera | 2006 | $ 472,000 | 33 | .323 | .947 | 33 |
Mark McGwire | 1989 | $ 510,500 | 32 | .260 | .830 | 49 |
Dave Kingman | 1986 | $ 730,000 | 30 | .238 | .726 | 35 |
Albert Pujols | 2003 | $ 900,000 | 34 | .314 | .955 | 37 |
Tony Armas | 1985 | $ 915,000 | 43 | .268 | .831 | 36 |
Dave Parker | 1987 | $ 1,100,000 | 31 | .273 | .807 | 34 |
Richie Sexson | 2001 | $ 1,125,000 | 30 | .272 | .848 | 31 |
Nomar Garciaparra | 1999 | $ 1,400,000 | 35 | .323 | .946 | 30 |
Fred McGriff | 1990 | $ 1,450,000 | 36 | .269 | .924 | 34 |
Darryl Strawberry | 1989 | $ 1,495,000 | 39 | .269 | .911 | 39 |
Mark McGwire | 1990 | $ 1,500,000 | 33 | .231 | .806 | 32 |
Cabrera should get battle pay for the atrocities he will see on the field this year. The only thrills for the Marlins will be measured by how badly the perform. Will they be worse than the 2003 Tigers? The 1962 Mets? The 1899 Cleveland Spiders? Will Dontrelle Willis have a season on par with Steve Carlton in 1972? Carlton won a Cy Young despite how woefully his Phils performed that year (he collected 27 of their 59 wins). How far down can their attendance go, triple digits per home game?
At least the Marlins fans' (if there are any left) loss will be my gain. I can't wait for the historic pain to begin. Dare I dream that they will out-bad even the Spiders? Dare. Dare.
The CBA sets up the system by which players get arbitration and can become free agents. Cabrera does not yet qualify. Therefore, he can accept the team's offer or sit out. I guess he pushed it as far as he could--it is spring training. And sitting out is aided by the press trumpeting your case, something that's hard to do from Venezuela, where Cabrera's from.
I expect him to get traded just before he becomes arbitration-eligible next year or the Marlins are folded and Loria becomes a minority owner in Boston (thereby, allowing him to become a Red Sock), whichever comes first.
I should be surprised that Loria is allowed to pull this crap off, but then again, the owners did give him the Marlins after he ran the Expos into the ground -- an act that by itself should have made Congress revoke MLB's antitrust exemptions.
Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.