Baseball Toaster was unplugged on February 4, 2009.
LVMVP! LVMVP! LVMVP!
Tonight Miguel Tejada failed in an attempt to extend his hitting streak to six games. In his previous five games the reigning AL MVP was batting .313. That sounds great, right?
Well after an 0-for-3 tonight, Tejada's batting average dipped to .176. It has been as low as .155 on April 25 and has not been over the Mendoza line of .200 since April 14.
What's more, even with five home runs, his slugging average sits at .308. It had been below .300 on April 25 and has not been over .400 since April 10.
His on-base percentage is .245, was as low as .218 on April 24, and has not been over .300 since April 10 (the only day this season it's been over .300).
His OPS (on-base plus slugging) is a miserable .554 and has not been over .600 since April 14.
For comparison's sake, Tejada did not have a day in 2002 on which his batting average was under .232, his OBP was under .250, his slugging average was under .350, or his OPS was under .600. His batting average is almost 90 points below his career average, his OBP is about 80 below, his slugging average is almost 150 points below, and his OPS, 225 points below his career average. Add to this the fact that he has made 8 errors in 31 games, which translates into slightly less than 42 over a full season, 16 more than he committed in his worst defensive season, his rookie one.
He's having a bad year, it would seem.
It got me to thinking if Tejada continues like this, however unlikely, would he be the LVMVP ever. LVMVP is something I just made up to stand for Least Valuable MVP, the player who plays the poorest while serving as the reigning MVP.
Let's take a look, shall we?
Here are the lowest batting averages for reigning MVPs:
BA Player, Year .207 Roy Campanella, 1954 .213 Kirk Gibson, 1989 .219 Roy Campanella, 1956 .226 Jeff Burroughs, 1975 .238 Roger Peckinpaugh, 1926 .238 Johnny Bench, 1971 .247 Robin Yount, 1990 .248 Orlando Cepeda, 1968 .249 Joe Gordon, 1943 .249 Zoilo Versalles, 1966 .250 Don Baylor, 1980
It seems like a lot of middle infielders, catchers, and older players. Burroughs and Versalles are probably the two guys thought of as the worst (or best) LVMVPs. By the way, no one ever batted under .200.
Now, here are the men with OPS's under .700 as reigning MVPs:
OPS Name, Year .653 Zoilo Versalles, 1966 .657 Don Baylor, 1980 .659 Roger Peckinpaugh, 1926 .670 Johnny Evers, 1915 .676 Willie McGee, 1986 .679 Kirk Gibson, 1989 .680 Bob O'Farrell, 1927 .685 Orlando Cepeda, 1968 .686 Roy Campanella, 1954 .687 Dick Groat, 1961 .689 Cal Ripken Jr., 1992 .696 Phil Rizzuto, 1951 .699 Frankie Frisch, 1932
There are a lot of the same suspects in that list. The new ones are of the same type: middle INFs, Cs, and aging stars.
Well, Tejada certainly is a middle infielder but the only such players who are a good match for him are Ripken, Versalles, and maybe Gordon (Yount was already a center fielder when he won his second MVP in 1989).
I hope that Tejada's career does not follow that group's: Versalles was washed up at 26 and Gordon and Ripken, though both have pretty good credentials for the Hall of Fame, had more down years than good ones after winning the MVP (i.e., Ripken's second MVP).
Versalles in 1965 led his team to a division championship. In two years he had been traded to the Dodgers, in four he had been drafted by the expansion Expos, and in five was playing in the Mexican League.
Tejada is only 26 (he'll turn 27 on the 25th), and should have plenty of great baseball left in him. But that's what everyone though about Zoilo Versalles in 1966.
[By the way, here are the LVMVP pitchers by ERA (note that Chandler only pitched one game that year):
ERA Name, Year 4.50 Spud Chandler, 1944 4.16 Dennis Eckersley, 1993 4.09 Bobby Shantz, 1953 4.05 Jim Konstanty, 1951 3.53 Dazzy Vance, 1925 3.49 Don Newcombe, 1957
And wins:
W Name, Year 0 Spud Chandler, 1944 2 Dennis Eckersley, 1993 4 Jim Konstanty, 1951 5 Bobby Shantz, 1953 5 Rollie Fingers, 1982 6 Vida Blue, 1972 8 Willie Hernandez, 1985 11 Don Newcombe, 1957]
Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.