Baseball Toaster Mike's Baseball Rants
This is my site with my opinions, but I hope that, like Irish Spring, you like it, too.
Frozen Toast
Google Search
Mike's Baseball Rants


10  09  07 
06  05  04  03 

12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

12  11  10  09  08  07 
Links to MBBR
Plan X?
2006-11-27 22:34
by Mike Carminati

The Phils appear to be spinning their wheels this offseason.

Plan A was to get Alfonzo Soriano to supplant fan pariah Pat Burrell to "protect MVP Ryan Howard". Soriano signed an eight-year, $136M contract with the Cubs.

Enter stage right, Plan B: Sign Carlos Lee to (again) replace Burrell. Lee gets six years and $100M from the Astros.

Next, insert foot in mouth.

The best remaining free agent left fielder is Barry Bonds, who is, of course, the greatest player of his era, but is also 42, is oft-inured, and comes with a ton of baggage.

Frank Catalanotto? Already signed with Texas.

There's always David Dellucci but he played for the team last year and couldn't displace Burrell in either left field or in the lineup. If he re-signs, it will probably be to play right with Shane Victorino is center (and Aaron Rowand reportedly traded back to the White Sox).

Meanwhile, the catcher the Phils reportedly were interested in, and who expressed interest in playing in Philly, Johnny Estrada got traded to the Brewers. The only desirable catcher on the free agent market is aging future Hall-of-Famer Mike Piazza. But why worry about a catcher when we are trying to get a marginal improvement in left field?

At third, the Phils have plugged in career backup Wes Helms coming off a career year. He'll platoon with Abraham O'Nunez. Lovely, and you thought they couldn't do worse than David Bell. Never mind that Aramis Ramirez was a free agent for a short time until he re-signed with the Cubs.

So what's next?

The Red Sox are reportedly shopping Manny Ramirez in anticipation of signing Phillie favorite J.D. Drew and potential woe fellow Scott Boras client Daisuke Matsuzaka. There are a number of teams interested in Ramirez but apparently the Phils are not among them.

I just don't get it. If the highest priority is to replace Burrell with a bigger bat, Ramirez is the ideal choice. And the Red Sox are motivated to move him.

So it appears that the Phils master plan to get a negligible improvement in left is going to fall through. They have already consigned the starting rotation to mediocrity by signing another tail-end starter in Adam Eaton (reportedly at three years and $24M). Unless Cole Hammels because a staff savior in 2007, their rotation may continue to be an immense problem.

Then there's the starting catcher. The Phils have only career minor-leaguer and 34-year-old rookie sensation Chris Coste or 27-year-old untried rookie Carlos Ruiz to depend on.

There's another hole in right. A lineup with both Rowand and Victorino in it will be problematic.

Then there's the depleted bullpen.

That's what happens when you put your eggs in one, or in this case two, baskets. The Phils would have been better served foregoing the fan sop of replacing Burrell and instead could have fixed the actual problems on the team.

But now it appears to late even though it really isn't. That's what a bad plan does to a team.

I thought Pat Gillick was an improvement over Ed Wade because he had a) a plan and b) some competency. But maybe a bad plan is worse than no plan at all. The Phils seem like a lock for another win total in the mid-80s next year. The older pitchers and lack of talent at key positions might cause an implosion, but then again how badly can a team collapse with two stars of Howard and Utley's caliber in the lineup?

I can't wait for Plan Y.

2006-11-28 05:55:52
1.   dianagramr
Watch Howard get walked 200 times next year .... sigh.
2006-11-28 06:14:38
2.   jakewoods
They didnt want to pay Abreu for 2 more yrs yet they wanted to pay Lee, an inferior player, for 7

makes sense

2006-11-28 12:41:12
3.   Balls Sticks Stuff
From everything I have read, the Phils weren't actually interested in Carlos Lee, so I wouldn't chalk that up to another failure or bad idea.

I'm not crazy about how the offseason is going either, but what else can they do? Would you rather they had outbid the Cubs for Aramis Ramirez? Do you actually think Manny is a good idea? Offer Zito and Schmidt $25M/yr. to come here?

2006-11-28 12:49:11
4.   das411
Mike, if you don't already I would suggest you check out some of the convo over at, they have a rather different take on this offseason so far...
2006-11-29 19:11:16
5.   Yu-Hsing Chen
Yeah if only the Phillies have a trio of near hall of famers at RF/3B/SP ... like... Bobby Abreu/ Scott Rolen/ Curt Schilling!! oh wait.... DOH!!!

seriously this is looking bad, and with the workload Hamels had this year he's a poor bet to stay healthy next year.

2006-12-07 06:24:06
6.   PhillyJ
Well, let's give him credit for a very nice move yesterday...Garcia significantly improves the staff with Lieber/Rowand/Burrell to use as chits for bullpen and Howard protection.

Stand Pat's patience seems to have paid off.

Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.