Baseball Toaster was unplugged on February 4, 2009.
As I watched the Mets shellack the Dodgers, 4-1, tonightif you're entire offense is Wilson Betemit, you've had a bad nightand inch closer to my prediction of a sweep, I couldn't help but notice, being a Phils fan and all, that there seem to be more ex-Phils strewn across the various playoff rosters than Phils on their current roster, given that half the team is one the way out of the revolving door that constitutes the team's short-, middle-, and long-range plans. The Mets had Endy Chavez start in right, called in Billy Wagner to close, and pinch-hit with Julio Franco while the Dodgers (inexplicably) started ex-Phils second baseman Marlon Anderson in left.
There are actually four former Philly third basemen peppering the various playoff rosters: Franco (who was mostly a shortstop when the Phils promoted him three decades ago), Nick Punto in Minnesota, ex-"Clubhouse Cancer" Scot Rolen, and Placido Polanco. In total their 16 ex-Phillies still active in the postseason. Besides the ones already mentioned there are Carlos Silva, Michael Tucker, Bobby Abreu, Sal Fasano Corey Lidle, Todd Jones, Josh Hancock, Gary Bennett, and the infamous Robert Horrendous.
I wondered if this was some sort of "record". Was there ever another team that had more ex-teammates playing in the postseason while that team sat at home and watched the playoffs on TV?
It turns out that the Phils don't hold the "record", but they are up there:
Yr/Tm | Total |
1998 Seattle Mariners | 20 |
1999 Los Angeles Dodgers | 17 |
2000 Cleveland Indians | 17 |
2001 San Diego Padres | 17 |
2004 Toronto Blue Jays | 17 |
1981 Chicago Cubs | 16 |
1995 Montreal Expos | 16 |
2000 Baltimore Orioles | 16 |
2004 Cleveland Indians | 16 |
1981 St. Louis Cardinals | 15 |
1999 Toronto Blue Jays | 15 |
2001 Toronto Blue Jays | 15 |
2002 New York Mets | 15 |
2003 Colorado Rockies | 15 |
You might think that this preoccupation with ex-Phils is rather odd, but if you followed the team, you would know that seeing an odd Nick Punto or Gary Bennett make it to the World Series, it's as if the Phils made it there. That's as close as we get besides the occasional Series lambasting every decade or so. It's like cheering for your team's sole All-Star rep even if it is Wayne Twitchell.
Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.