Baseball Toaster was unplugged on February 4, 2009.
I have been compiling a plethora of information based on Retrosheet data, and tonight I ran into some interesting results. Given that I never met a table I didn't like, I hereby present the all-time leaders in percent of regular season days spent in first place:
Franchise | Lg | % in 1st | % Last |
New York Yankees | AL | 34.20% | 4.17% |
Arizona Diamondbacks | NL | 33.96% | 23.98% |
San Francisco Giants | NL | 23.32% | 6.74% |
Los Angeles Dodgers | NL | 21.30% | 5.12% |
Oakland Athletics | AL | 18.79% | 20.40% |
St. Louis Cardinals | NL | 18.26% | 7.85% |
Atlanta Braves | NL | 17.69% | 12.46% |
Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim | AL | 16.73% | 12.30% |
Seattle Mariners | AL | 16.67% | 25.22% |
Houston Astros | NL | 16.63% | 10.83% |
And here are the all-time worst:
Franchise | Lg | % in 1st | % Last |
Tampa Bay Devil Rays | AL | 1.66% | 73.32% |
Florida Marlins | NL | 6.93% | 24.13% |
Milwaukee Brewers | NL | 7.27% | 20.07% |
Colorado Rockies | NL | 7.94% | 26.86% |
Washington Nationals | NL | 9.22% | 18.40% |
Philadelphia Phillies | NL | 9.78% | 21.91% |
Minnesota Twins | AL | 10.90% | 13.16% |
New York Mets | NL | 11.17% | 25.67% |
Baltimore Orioles | AL | 11.56% | 16.34% |
San Diego Padres | NL | 11.78% | 33.91% |
No surprises in the leaders (the Yankees and Tampa Bay, who have spent a grand total of 24 days in first place) on those lists. However, the all-time best among defunct clubs, the American Association's Boston Reds, who spent over 83% of their time in first, would not be the first club one thinks of. (By the way, 25 defunct clubs have spent not one day in first, tying for the all-time worst.)
Now for the least amount of time in last place in whatever division or league configuration that prevailed at the time:
Franchise | Lg | % in 1st | % Last |
New York Yankees | AL | 34.20% | 4.17% |
Los Angeles Dodgers | NL | 21.30% | 5.12% |
San Francisco Giants | NL | 23.32% | 6.74% |
St. Louis Cardinals | NL | 18.26% | 7.85% |
Chicago White Sox | AL | 13.86% | 7.94% |
Chicago Cubs | NL | 15.65% | 8.88% |
Cincinnati Reds | NL | 13.39% | 9.90% |
Cleveland Indians | AL | 14.39% | 10.19% |
Houston Astros | NL | 16.63% | 10.83% |
Boston Red Sox | AL | 15.27% | 11.26% |
Now, the teams that spent the most time in last place:
Franchise | Lg | % in 1st | % Last |
Tampa Bay Devil Rays | AL | 1.66% | 73.32% |
San Diego Padres | NL | 11.78% | 33.91% |
Colorado Rockies | NL | 7.94% | 26.86% |
New York Mets | NL | 11.17% | 25.67% |
Texas Rangers | AL | 12.04% | 25.48% |
Seattle Mariners | AL | 16.67% | 25.22% |
Florida Marlins | NL | 6.93% | 24.13% |
Arizona Diamondbacks | NL | 33.96% | 23.98% |
Toronto Blue Jays | AL | 16.41% | 22.71% |
Philadelphia Phillies | NL | 9.78% | 21.91% |
To get a truer picture, let's look at the ratio of days in first to days in last:
Franchise | Lg | % in 1st | % Last | First-Last Ratio |
New York Yankees | AL | 34.20% | 4.17% | 8.19 |
Los Angeles Dodgers | NL | 21.30% | 5.12% | 4.16 |
San Francisco Giants | NL | 23.32% | 6.74% | 3.46 |
St. Louis Cardinals | NL | 18.26% | 7.85% | 2.32 |
Chicago Cubs | NL | 15.65% | 8.88% | 1.76 |
Chicago White Sox | AL | 13.86% | 7.94% | 1.75 |
Houston Astros | NL | 16.63% | 10.83% | 1.54 |
Atlanta Braves | NL | 17.69% | 12.46% | 1.42 |
Arizona Diamondbacks | NL | 33.96% | 23.98% | 1.42 |
Cleveland Indians | AL | 14.39% | 10.19% | 1.41 |
Now the worst ratios:
Franchise | Lg | % in 1st | % Last | First-Last Ratio |
Tampa Bay Devil Rays | AL | 1.66% | 73.32% | 0.02 |
Florida Marlins | NL | 6.93% | 24.13% | 0.29 |
Colorado Rockies | NL | 7.94% | 26.86% | 0.30 |
San Diego Padres | NL | 11.78% | 33.91% | 0.35 |
Milwaukee Brewers | NL | 7.27% | 20.07% | 0.36 |
New York Mets | NL | 11.17% | 25.67% | 0.43 |
Philadelphia Phillies | NL | 9.78% | 21.91% | 0.45 |
Texas Rangers | AL | 12.04% | 25.48% | 0.47 |
Washington Nationals | NL | 9.22% | 18.40% | 0.50 |
Seattle Mariners | AL | 16.67% | 25.22% | 0.66 |
Of course, the Phillies are the worst of the original 16 teams.
As for the average position for each teams, here are the best (not that expansion teams get a boost from being in smaller groupings):
Franchise | Lg | POS Avg |
Arizona Diamondbacks | NL | 2.64 |
New York Yankees | AL | 2.93 |
San Francisco Giants | NL | 3.38 |
Kansas City Royals | AL | 3.46 |
Washington Nationals | NL | 3.53 |
Florida Marlins | NL | 3.64 |
Toronto Blue Jays | AL | 3.69 |
Colorado Rockies | NL | 3.72 |
Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim | AL | 3.74 |
Los Angeles Dodgers | NL | 3.77 |
Now the worst average position teams:
Franchise | Lg | POS Avg |
Philadelphia Phillies | NL | 4.78 |
Baltimore Orioles | AL | 4.67 |
Tampa Bay Devil Rays | AL | 4.57 |
Minnesota Twins | AL | 4.53 |
Texas Rangers | AL | 4.43 |
Oakland Athletics | AL | 4.41 |
New York Mets | NL | 4.35 |
Atlanta Braves | NL | 4.24 |
Cincinnati Reds | NL | 4.19 |
Milwaukee Brewers | NL | 4.14 |
Seattle Mariners | AL | 4.14 |
Pittsburgh Pirates | NL | 4.14 |
Ah, it makes one proud to be a Phillies fan. Will someone please contract my team and free me from this curse?
I assume when you say "San Francisco Giants" or "Los Angeles Dodgers" you're including the time both teams spent in New York? Because my off-the-cuff imaginings tell me the San Francisco Giants have only been intermittently successful.
Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.