Baseball Toaster Mike's Baseball Rants
Help
This is my site with my opinions, but I hope that, like Irish Spring, you like it, too.
Frozen Toast
Search
Google Search
Web
Toaster
Mike's Baseball Rants
Archives

2009
01 

2008
10  09  07 
06  05  04  03 

2007
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2006
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2005
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2004
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2003
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2002
12  11  10  09  08  07 
Links to MBBR
Waiting for Mad Dog
2006-04-20 11:45
by Mike Carminati
We are all born mad (dog). Some remain so.
— From "Waiting for Godot" by Samuel "Don't Call Me Josh" Beckett

Not all players in their forties are struggling to achieve mediocrity. Two ex-Braves are leading the National League in ERA. They are, of course, Greg Maddux (1.33) and Tom Glavine (1.38).

Maddux, with Roger Clemens on hiatus, becomes the active leader in wins. He is now reminding fans that until the last few years, the debate as to whom was the best pitcher of his era, him or Clemens, was a hot topic. Maddux, a sure-fire Hall of Famer, saw his star tarnish the last few years but seems reborn this year.

With three wins, he no projects to—what?—forty or so for the season and comparison's to Old Hoss Radbourne abound. However, realistically a return to twenty wins is a definite possibility for Maddux. It would be his third twenty-win season but his first since 1993 (even though he has won two Cy Youngs since then).

That made me wonder what was the longest gap between twenty-win seasons for a pitcher in baseball history. Would 13 years be a new "record"?

The answer is that ten seasons is the most and it was down twice, once recently by a player who won twenty the first time with the Mets and the second time with the Yankees (Who else can say that?). There have only been 25 gaps of five seasons or more. Maddux's ex-teammate Glavine makes the list as does Phil Niekro, another ex-Brave…twice!

NameYr1WL ERA Yr2WL ERA #Yrs
Bert Cunningham18882229 3.39 18982815 3.16 10
David Cone1988203 2.22 1998207 3.55 10
George Bradley18764519 1.23 18842515 2.71 8
Jim Kaat19662513 2.75 19742113 2.92 8
Andy Pettitte1996218 3.87 2003218 4.02 7
Billy Rhines18902817 1.95 18972115 4.08 7
Bobby Mathews18762134 2.86 18833013 2.46 7
Ed Reulbach1908247 2.03 19152110 2.23 7
Roger Clemens1990216 1.93 1997217 2.05 7
Bill Donovan19012515 2.77 1907254 2.19 6
Eppa Rixey19162210 1.85 19222513 3.53 6
Jack Morris1986218 3.27 1992216 4.04 6
Adonis Terry18902616 2.94 18952114 4.80 5
Al Orth19012012 2.27 19062717 2.34 5
Bob Feller19412513 3.15 19462615 2.18 5
Brickyard Kennedy18942420 4.92 1899229 2.79 5
Frank Lary19562113 3.15 1961239 3.24 5
Kid Nichols18992119 2.99 19042113 2.02 5
Luis Tiant1968219 1.60 19732013 3.34 5
Phil Niekro19692313 2.56 19742013 2.38 5
Phil Niekro19742013 2.38 19792120 3.39 5
Red Faber19152414 2.55 19202313 2.99 5
Ron Guidry1978253 1.74 1983219 3.42 5
Tom Glavine1993226 3.20 1998206 2.47 5
Walter Johnson19192014 1.49 1924237 2.72 5

Bert Cunningham, you might recall, was Richie's brother in the original Happy Days lineup. I've never heard of this Cone guy though.

Back to Maddux: If he wins twenty, it'll be just the eighth time in baseball history that a forty-something pitcher has done so:

NameYrWL ERA Age
Warren Spahn1963237 2.60 42
Cy Young19082111 1.26 41
Phil Niekro19792120 3.39 40
Cy Young19072115 1.99 40
Jamie Moyer2003217 3.27 40
Pete Alexander19272110 2.52 40
Warren Spahn19612113 3.02 40
Eddie Plank19152111 2.08 39
Gaylord Perry1978216 2.73 39
Warren Spahn19602110 3.50 39
Early Wynn19592210 3.17 39
Spud Chandler1946208 2.10 38
Roger Clemens2001203 3.51 38
Jamie Moyer2001206 3.43 38
Warren Spahn19592115 2.96 38
Randy Johnson2002245 2.32 38

Even if Maddux does not win twenty, he seems like a lock to win at least 15. If so, he will tie Cy Young for the most 15-win seasons ever:

Name#Yrs
Cy Young18
Greg Maddux17
Walter Johnson16
Warren Spahn16
Eddie Plank15
Pete Alexander15
Tom Seaver13
Phil Niekro13
Gaylord Perry13
Christy Mathewson13
Steve Carlton12
Don Sutton12
Jim Palmer12
Jack Morris12
Roger Clemens12
Kid Nichols12
Red Ruffing11
Jack Taylor11
Pud Galvin11
Lefty Grove11
Burleigh Grimes11
Tim Keefe11
Mickey Welch10
Gus Weyhing10
Bob Feller10
Early Wynn10
Fergie Jenkins10
Randy Johnson10
Bert Blyleven10
Robin Roberts10
Whitey Ford10
Bob Gibson10

Speaking of which, there was a time when it seemed that the Cy Young Award would be renamed the Greg Maddux. If he wins one this year, it'll be one for Jerome Bettis's thumb, or words to that effect. Here are the multiple Cy Young winners:

Roger Clemens7
Randy Johnson5
Greg Maddux4
Steve Carlton4
Pedro Martinez3
Jim Palmer3
Tom Seaver3
Sandy Koufax3
Gaylord Perry2
Denny McLain2
Bob Gibson2
Bret Saberhagen2
Tom Glavine2

So as Maddux and Glavine return to their old glories, the Braves top winner—and the league's—is reliever Oscar Villarreal. He could become the first twenty-game winner to never start a game. Here are the most wins without a start in season:

NameYrGWL ERA
Roy Face195957181 2.70
Bill Campbell197678175 3.01
John Hiller1974591714 2.64
Dick Radatz196479169 2.29
Jim Konstanty195074167 2.66
Ron Perranoski196369163 1.67
Tom Johnson197771167 3.13
Dale Murray197563158 3.96
Dick Radatz196366156 1.97
Eddie Fisher196582157 2.40
Hoyt Wilhelm195271153 2.43
Luis Arroyo196165155 2.19
Mike Marshall19741061512 2.42
Frank Linzy196958149 3.64
Hersh Freeman195664145 3.40
Jim Slaton198346146 4.33
Mark Clear198255149 3.00
Mark Eichhorn198669146 1.72
Mike Marshall197265148 1.78
Mike Marshall1973921411 2.66
Phil Regan196665141 1.62
Roger McDowell198675149 3.02
Ron Davis197944142 2.85
Stu Miller196163145 2.66
Stu Miller196567147 1.89
Comments
2006-04-20 12:43:40
1.   Bob Timmermann
Bert Cunningham holds the record for most wild pitches in an inning with 5.
2006-04-20 12:58:37
2.   Mike Carminati
He also threw two complete games on August 20, 1890. Later became an ump and had Jimmy Sheckard spit in his face a la Roberto Alomar.
2006-04-20 14:36:21
3.   das411
Did Konstanty win the Cy that year Mike?

Also, how in the world is MARK EICHHORN on that list?? That's the same dude from those evil evil '93 Jays right?

2006-04-20 15:33:00
4.   NoPepperGames
Can I ask where you got your database from? Those reports are pretty damned sweet. I wouldn't get a lick of work done with that.
2006-04-21 05:47:25
5.   markh
How the heck do you go 17-14 without starting a single game? On a team with average starters and a lousy offense? I'm pretty impressed.
2006-04-25 06:37:52
6.   PhillyJ
The most striking quote in the piece:

"Even if Maddux does not win twenty, he seems like a lock to win at least 15. If so, he will tie Cy Young for the most 15-win seasons ever"

Impressive...

And by the way, I could have sworn Richie Cunningham's long lost brother was named Chuck!

Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.