Baseball Toaster was unplugged on February 4, 2009.
So who were the most prolific home-run hitting teammates of all time? It sure wasn't Canseco and McGwire.
I looked at the home run records for all teammates who hit at least 100 homers individually, and here they are:
| Franchise | # Yrs | Player 1 | HR1 | Player 2 | HR2 | Tot HR |
| Atlanta Braves | 13 | Hank Aaron | 442 | Eddie Mathews | 421 | 863 |
| New York Yankees | 12 | Babe Ruth | 511 | Lou Gehrig | 348 | 859 |
| San Francisco Giants | 14 | Willie Mays | 430 | Willie McCovey | 384 | 814 |
| Los Angeles Dodgers | 15 | Duke Snider | 384 | Gil Hodges | 361 | 745 |
| Boston Red Sox | 16 | Jim Rice | 382 | Dwight Evans | 355 | 737 |
| Minnesota Twins | 13 | Harmon Killebrew | 476 | Bob Allison | 256 | 732 |
| Chicago Cubs | 14 | Billy Williams | 376 | Ron Santo | 337 | 713 |
| New York Yankees | 13 | Mickey Mantle | 419 | Yogi Berra | 283 | 702 |
| Houston Astros | 15 | Jeff Bagwell | 449 | Craig Biggio | 222 | 671 |
| Seattle Mariners | 11 | Ken Griffey | 398 | Jay Buhner | 269 | 667 |
| Chicago Cubs | 13 | Ernie Banks | 329 | Billy Williams | 319 | 648 |
| Detroit Tigers | 15 | Norm Cash | 373 | Al Kaline | 274 | 647 |
| Minnesota Twins | 13 | Harmon Killebrew | 429 | Tony Oliva | 206 | 635 |
| Atlanta Braves | 10 | Eddie Mathews | 374 | Joe Adcock | 239 | 613 |
| New York Yankees | 10 | Babe Ruth | 467 | Bob Meusel | 146 | 613 |
| New York Yankees | 12 | Lou Gehrig | 443 | Tony Lazzeri | 169 | 612 |
| Seattle Mariners | 11 | Ken Griffey | 398 | Edgar Martinez | 198 | 596 |
| New York Yankees | 13 | Mickey Mantle | 434 | Elston Howard | 161 | 595 |
| New York Yankees | 12 | Lou Gehrig | 409 | Bill Dickey | 178 | 587 |
| Chicago Cubs | 12 | Ron Santo | 300 | Ernie Banks | 284 | 584 |
| San Francisco Giants | 9 | Willie Mays | 355 | Orlando Cepeda | 226 | 581 |
| Seattle Mariners | 14 | Jay Buhner | 307 | Edgar Martinez | 258 | 565 |
| Atlanta Braves | 10 | Chipper Jones | 294 | Andruw Jones | 270 | 564 |
| Atlanta Braves | 11 | Eddie Mathews | 397 | Del Crandall | 162 | 559 |
| Detroit Tigers | 14 | Norm Cash | 366 | Dick McAuliffe | 192 | 558 |
| Los Angeles Dodgers | 10 | Duke Snider | 316 | Roy Campanella | 242 | 558 |
| Los Angeles Dodgers | 14 | Duke Snider | 368 | Carl Furillo | 189 | 557 |
| Los Angeles Dodgers | 14 | Gil Hodges | 353 | Carl Furillo | 189 | 542 |
| Los Angeles Dodgers | 10 | Gil Hodges | 297 | Roy Campanella | 242 | 539 |
| Baltimore Orioles | 14 | Boog Powell | 303 | Brooks Robinson | 234 | 537 |
There are two current pairings on the list, the so-called Killer Bs of Houston and the Jones Boys in Atlanta. So where are the Bash Brothers? They crack the list at a meager number 41 with 503 home runs in eight years (McGwire 254 and Canseco 249), tied with Schmitty and the Bull and just three dingers behind Juan Gone and Pudge in Texas.
Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.