Baseball Toaster Mike's Baseball Rants
Help
This is my site with my opinions, but I hope that, like Irish Spring, you like it, too.
Frozen Toast
Search
Google Search
Web
Toaster
Mike's Baseball Rants
Archives

2009
01 

2008
10  09  07 
06  05  04  03 

2007
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2006
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2005
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2004
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2003
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2002
12  11  10  09  08  07 
Links to MBBR
Competitive Balancing Act II, Scene III—This Is Pop: Redefining Large- and Small-Market by Population
2004-04-17 01:33
by Mike Carminati

Other entries in the series:

Competitive Balancing Act I—The King James Version: An Overview of the Literature, Scenes I, II, III, and IV
Competitive Balancing Act II—This Is Pop: Redefining Large- and Small-Market by Population, Scenes I, II, and III
Competitive Balancing Act III—C'mon Freddy, Everyone into the Poo-el: Reviewing the Available Player Pool
Competitive Balancing Act IV—Natural Resources: Attendance and Competitive Balance

The previous section contained an anecdotal history of the team movements and expansions to new markets, a nice and easy review. "Y' know, every now and then I think you might like to hear something nice and easy. But there's just one thing: you see, we never ever do nothing nice and easy. We always do it nice and rough. So…we're gonna do the finish rough." (Thank you, Tina)

What would one of my studies without heaping gobs of tables? So here goes. First is a comparison of large and small market teams using various stats:

Yr#PCTPOSATT/GBAOBPSLUGOPSERA
18710.501.470.43N/A1.031.031.011.020.85
18720.221.480.45N/A1.051.091.021.050.67
18730.801.100.71N/A0.940.950.910.930.91
18740.601.050.94N/A0.910.920.870.890.94
18750.441.050.95N/A1.071.061.071.070.99
18760.600.941.06N/A1.111.091.131.111.22
18770.200.861.56N/A1.031.031.011.021.25
18780.000.000.00N/A0.000.000.000.000.00
18790.141.190.88N/A1.021.021.031.030.98
18800.141.750.20N/A1.171.161.151.150.79
18810.141.400.20N/A1.161.141.141.140.86
18820.560.990.83N/A0.991.000.960.981.07
18831.291.120.74N/A1.011.001.031.020.92
18841.001.130.69N/A1.061.071.091.080.96
18851.291.150.82N/A1.041.041.071.061.00
18861.291.091.09N/A0.990.990.980.981.02
18871.671.240.67N/A1.031.041.041.040.93
18881.291.440.41N/A1.041.051.091.070.75
18891.291.510.41N/A1.041.061.081.070.79
18901.271.070.95N/A1.021.001.051.021.00
18910.701.140.68N/A1.031.021.051.031.00
18921.001.140.77N/A1.031.041.031.041.00
18931.001.080.86N/A1.021.001.051.020.92
18941.001.180.66N/A1.051.031.041.040.96
18951.001.020.95N/A0.991.000.991.001.07
18961.000.901.36N/A0.980.980.990.981.11
18971.000.931.17N/A1.000.991.011.001.09
18981.000.951.05N/A0.990.981.000.990.99
18991.001.300.59N/A1.031.041.041.040.83
19001.671.011.06N/A1.031.041.011.021.07
19011.291.020.921.151.031.021.021.021.02
19021.000.921.251.170.980.990.960.981.01
19031.291.170.701.241.031.051.021.030.98
19041.291.210.741.271.041.041.061.050.90
19051.291.280.621.491.061.051.061.060.86
19061.291.470.411.611.071.081.071.080.81
19071.291.330.521.501.001.031.011.020.87
19081.291.130.781.300.991.021.001.010.96
19091.291.250.701.341.001.001.041.020.81
19101.291.250.561.261.021.011.041.020.87
19111.291.260.591.451.021.001.051.030.84
19121.291.011.091.301.021.011.011.011.01
19131.291.150.701.711.031.021.041.030.92
19141.181.030.951.101.021.021.021.021.00
19151.180.921.181.190.991.001.011.011.15
19161.291.060.741.641.031.021.061.041.01
19171.291.110.821.771.011.021.021.020.92
19181.291.001.031.461.001.000.991.001.08
19191.291.070.781.571.031.011.061.041.04
19201.291.070.871.860.991.001.031.010.96
19211.290.921.301.581.011.031.031.031.10
19221.291.020.921.391.011.021.011.011.04
19231.291.050.871.681.031.041.051.051.04
19241.291.040.921.541.011.031.031.031.07
19251.290.961.461.310.991.000.991.001.04
19261.291.070.971.381.001.011.011.010.94
19271.291.070.921.521.021.031.051.040.97
19281.291.050.971.511.001.011.031.020.97
19291.291.140.702.121.041.041.111.081.00
19301.291.100.821.901.051.051.091.071.02
19311.291.080.821.721.041.061.091.071.03
19321.291.160.701.801.041.051.101.081.00
19331.291.020.821.491.011.031.041.041.05
19341.291.080.821.671.021.031.051.041.01
19351.291.130.741.571.021.021.051.030.94
19361.291.030.851.511.031.031.041.031.00
19372.201.180.671.831.001.021.051.040.95
19382.201.030.911.370.961.000.970.990.99
19392.201.070.971.440.981.001.001.000.98
19402.200.971.101.460.991.001.001.000.98
19412.200.921.031.440.990.991.021.011.04
19422.200.951.181.411.000.990.990.991.03
19432.200.841.881.150.980.980.950.971.12
19441.290.931.151.421.001.000.980.991.09
19451.290.990.971.601.011.021.021.021.05
19460.781.050.921.520.991.021.001.010.94
19470.781.060.771.451.021.031.061.051.03
19480.780.981.291.300.990.991.000.990.98
19490.781.030.971.381.001.001.011.010.98
19500.781.040.871.461.010.991.041.020.96
19510.781.110.821.461.021.021.061.040.97
19520.780.980.821.411.011.001.021.011.00
19531.001.030.951.251.011.021.021.021.04
19541.001.080.801.031.021.021.041.030.98
19551.291.160.740.961.011.021.041.030.88
19561.291.040.970.951.021.021.031.020.95
19571.291.080.870.940.981.020.980.990.91
19581.291.020.921.071.031.031.051.041.02
19591.291.100.661.260.991.001.001.000.96
19601.290.951.301.240.991.000.990.991.01
19611.251.030.821.131.001.011.031.021.02
19621.501.040.801.311.001.011.011.011.02
19631.501.030.891.291.011.001.011.000.96
19641.501.040.931.301.011.000.991.000.95
19651.500.961.001.050.970.980.950.960.96
19661.500.971.121.010.980.990.980.991.02
19671.221.020.851.060.960.990.950.970.94
19681.000.931.391.200.940.970.970.971.07
19691.180.991.071.320.990.990.990.990.96
19701.000.951.241.330.980.990.950.971.01
19710.850.961.131.340.991.000.980.991.02
19720.850.991.021.400.970.990.960.970.99
19730.850.961.181.280.980.990.950.970.97
19740.850.971.181.271.011.011.001.001.04
19751.000.931.331.160.990.990.970.981.06
19761.000.981.051.240.980.980.990.981.00
19771.171.040.891.291.011.011.031.020.94
19781.171.010.931.291.021.011.001.011.00
19791.171.011.141.311.011.001.011.011.00
19801.170.991.101.351.011.011.011.011.03
19811.361.031.061.421.011.021.011.010.96
19821.361.021.161.181.001.011.001.010.98
19831.361.070.801.231.011.011.031.020.95
19841.171.090.821.431.011.011.051.030.94
19851.171.130.761.401.011.021.051.040.94
19861.171.130.671.351.021.021.031.030.96
19871.171.021.301.240.990.991.011.000.97
19881.170.981.011.121.001.001.011.011.04
19891.601.050.771.221.011.011.021.011.00
19901.601.080.711.240.991.001.001.000.98
19911.600.951.111.160.970.981.000.991.05
19921.600.961.291.210.960.990.980.991.03
19931.801.140.641.161.001.021.021.020.89
19941.801.040.861.100.981.000.991.000.95
19951.801.001.031.120.981.000.980.990.97
19961.800.951.030.950.970.970.980.970.98
19971.801.090.791.091.001.021.001.010.94
19981.731.100.710.941.021.021.041.030.98
19991.731.050.771.020.991.001.011.010.97
20001.731.040.771.061.001.011.031.020.99
20011.731.100.761.020.991.001.001.000.92
20021.731.160.811.271.021.021.041.030.90
20031.731.130.621.331.001.001.021.010.89
Avg1.221.070.891.341.001.011.011.010.97

Here are the minimum and maximum populations for all cities represented (prorated by team for multiple-team locations) as well as the cutoff and the percentage of the max each of the other two represents:

YrMax PopCityMin PopCityMin/MaxCutoff PopCity% Max
18711,521,463New York11,257Rockford0.74%319,398Chicago20.99%
18721,564,822New York6,904Middletown0.44%318,795St. Louis20.37%
18731,608,182New York23,051Elizabeth1.43%360,239Chicago22.40%
18741,651,541New York20,737Hartford1.26%380,660Chicago23.05%
18751,694,901New York12,442Keokuk0.73%306,533Boston18.09%
18761,738,260New York27,830Hartford1.60%421,502Chicago24.25%
1877441,923Chicago31,376Hartford7.10%441,923Chicago100.00%
1878462,343Chicago69,694Indianapolis15.07%532,550Brooklyn115.18%
1879482,764Chicago50,918Syracuse10.55%482,764Chicago100.00%
1880503,185Chicago56,747Troy11.28%503,185Chicago100.00%
1881562,852Chicago57,168Troy10.16%562,852Chicago100.00%
1882887,129Philadelphia57,589Troy6.49%352,738Baltimore39.76%
18831,045,206New York62,598Columbus5.99%267,670Cincinnati25.61%
18841,074,992New York23,961Altoona2.23%152,154Detroit14.15%
18851,104,778New York118,502Providence10.73%276,024Cincinnati24.98%
18861,134,564New York101,944Kansas City8.99%280,200Cincinnati24.70%
18871,164,350New York96,322Indianapolis8.27%284,377Cincinnati24.42%
18882,388,271New York99,360Indianapolis4.16%288,554Cincinnati12.08%
18892,447,842New York84,500Columbus3.45%292,731Cincinnati11.96%
18901,253,707New York81,434Toledo6.50%242,039New Orleans19.31%
18912,600,393New York91,891Columbus3.53%303,376San Francisco11.67%
18922,693,372New York145,849Louisville5.42%470,960Boston17.49%
18932,786,350New York153,210Louisville5.50%482,202Boston17.31%
18942,879,329New York160,570Louisville5.58%493,443Boston17.14%
18952,972,308New York167,930Louisville5.65%504,685Boston16.98%
18963,065,287New York175,290Louisville5.72%515,926Boston16.83%
18973,158,266New York182,650Louisville5.78%527,168Boston16.69%
18981,625,622New York190,011Louisville11.69%538,409Boston33.12%
18991,672,112New York197,371Louisville11.80%549,651Boston32.87%
19001,718,601New York321,616Pittsburgh18.71%575,238St. Louis33.47%
19011,785,083New York283,953Washington15.91%359,520Buffalo20.14%
19021,851,564New York289,188Washington15.62%366,653Buffalo19.80%
19031,278,697New York294,423Washington23.03%385,303Pittsburgh30.13%
19041,323,018New York299,658Washington22.65%406,532Pittsburgh30.73%
19051,367,339New York304,894Washington22.30%427,761Pittsburgh31.28%
19061,411,660New York310,129Washington21.97%448,989Pittsburgh31.81%
19071,455,981New York315,364Washington21.66%470,218Pittsburgh32.30%
19081,500,302New York320,599Washington21.37%491,447Pittsburgh32.76%
19091,544,623New York325,834Washington21.09%512,676Pittsburgh33.19%
19101,588,944New York331,069Washington20.84%533,905Pittsburgh33.60%
19111,617,385New York339,166Boston20.97%539,349Pittsburgh33.35%
19121,645,825New York343,040Boston20.84%571,348Detroit34.72%
19131,674,266New York346,914Boston20.72%611,087Baltimore36.50%
19141,277,030New York240,459St. Louis18.83%452,818San Francisco35.46%
19151,298,360New York243,321St. Louis18.74%461,794San Francisco35.57%
19161,759,587New York358,535Boston20.38%663,690Baltimore37.72%
19171,788,028New York362,409Boston20.27%681,224Baltimore38.10%
19181,816,468New York366,283Boston20.16%698,758Baltimore38.47%
19191,844,909New York370,156Boston20.06%716,292Baltimore38.83%
19201,873,349New York374,030Boston19.97%733,826Baltimore39.17%
19211,917,029New York375,686Boston19.60%740,931Baltimore38.65%
19221,960,709New York377,343Boston19.25%748,036Baltimore38.15%
19232,004,389New York378,999Boston18.91%757,998Boston37.82%
19242,048,069New York380,656Boston18.59%762,245Baltimore37.22%
19252,091,749New York382,312Boston18.28%769,350Baltimore36.78%
19262,135,429New York383,968Boston17.98%776,455Baltimore36.36%
19272,179,109New York385,625Boston17.70%783,560Baltimore35.96%
19282,222,789New York387,281Boston17.42%790,664Baltimore35.57%
19292,266,469New York388,938Boston17.16%797,769Baltimore35.20%
19302,310,149New York390,594Boston16.91%804,874Baltimore34.84%
19312,327,634New York410,684St. Louis17.64%821,369St. Louis35.29%
19322,345,119New York410,389St. Louis17.50%827,020Montreal35.27%
19332,362,604New York410,093St. Louis17.36%835,463Montreal35.36%
19342,380,089New York409,798St. Louis17.22%843,906Montreal35.46%
19352,397,574New York409,502St. Louis17.08%831,987Baltimore34.70%
19362,415,058New York409,206St. Louis16.94%837,410Baltimore34.67%
19372,432,543New York408,911St. Louis16.81%869,235Montreal35.73%
19382,450,028New York408,615St. Louis16.68%877,678Montreal35.82%
19392,467,513New York408,320St. Louis16.55%853,677Baltimore34.60%
19402,484,998New York408,024St. Louis16.42%878,336Cleveland35.35%
19412,666,898New York454,988St. Louis17.06%913,730Baltimore34.26%
19422,848,798New York501,953St. Louis17.62%1,003,905St. Louis35.24%
19433,030,698New York548,917St. Louis18.11%1,097,834St. Louis36.22%
19443,212,598New York595,881St. Louis18.55%1,235,095San Francisco38.45%
19453,394,498New York642,846St. Louis18.94%1,385,235San Francisco40.81%
19463,576,398New York689,810St. Louis19.29%1,535,375San Francisco42.93%
19473,758,298New York736,774St. Louis19.60%1,685,515San Francisco44.85%
19483,940,198New York783,738St. Louis19.89%1,835,654San Francisco46.59%
19494,122,098New York830,703St. Louis20.15%1,985,794San Francisco48.17%
19504,303,998New York877,667St. Louis20.39%2,135,934San Francisco49.63%
19514,387,090New York895,134St. Louis20.40%2,187,217San Francisco49.86%
19524,470,182New York912,601St. Louis20.42%2,238,500San Francisco50.08%
19534,553,274New York930,067St. Louis20.43%2,270,896Pittsburgh49.87%
19544,636,366New York1,099,725Milwaukee23.72%2,290,116Pittsburgh49.39%
19554,719,458New York970,600Kansas City20.57%2,309,336Pittsburgh48.93%
19564,802,550New York994,989Kansas City20.72%2,328,555Pittsburgh48.49%
19574,885,642New York1,019,378Kansas City20.86%2,372,417Cleveland48.56%
195814,906,204New York1,043,767Kansas City7.00%2,492,395Cleveland16.72%
195915,155,480New York1,068,156Kansas City7.05%2,597,479San Francisco17.14%
196015,404,756New York1,092,545Kansas City7.09%2,648,762San Francisco17.19%
196115,567,807New York1,110,683Kansas City7.13%2,436,817Montreal15.65%
19627,865,429New York1,128,821Kansas City14.35%2,404,674Pittsburgh30.57%
19637,946,955New York1,146,959Kansas City14.43%2,404,294Pittsburgh30.25%
19648,028,481New York1,165,097Kansas City14.51%2,403,914Pittsburgh29.94%
19658,110,007New York1,183,236Kansas City14.59%2,403,534Pittsburgh29.64%
19668,191,532New York1,201,374Kansas City14.67%2,403,153Pittsburgh29.34%
19678,273,058New York1,219,512Kansas City14.74%2,440,224Toronto29.50%
19688,354,584New York1,479,851Atlanta17.71%2,487,179Toronto29.77%
19698,436,109New York1,255,788Kansas City14.89%2,380,263St. Louis28.22%
19708,517,635New York1,273,926Kansas City14.96%2,410,884St. Louis28.30%
19718,471,936New York1,279,244Kansas City15.10%2,537,341Dallas-Fort Worth29.95%
19728,426,238New York1,284,562Kansas City15.24%2,565,857Nassau-Suffolk30.45%
19738,380,539New York1,289,880Kansas City15.39%2,570,852Nassau-Suffolk30.68%
19748,334,840New York1,295,198Kansas City15.54%2,575,846Nassau-Suffolk30.90%
19758,289,142New York1,300,516Kansas City15.69%2,635,211Houston31.79%
19768,243,443New York1,305,834Kansas City15.84%2,728,427Houston33.10%
19778,197,744New York1,311,152Kansas City15.99%2,602,962Cleveland31.75%
19788,152,046New York1,316,470Kansas City16.15%2,679,995Cleveland32.88%
19798,106,347New York1,321,788Kansas City16.31%2,757,029Cleveland34.01%
19808,060,649New York1,327,106Kansas City16.46%2,819,835Montreal34.98%
19818,221,684New York1,352,683Kansas City16.45%2,828,349Montreal34.40%
19828,382,720New York1,378,260Kansas City16.44%2,839,178Cleveland33.87%
19838,543,756New York1,403,837Kansas City16.43%2,841,737Cleveland33.26%
19848,704,792New York1,429,414Kansas City16.42%2,863,421Miami32.89%
19858,865,828New York1,454,991Kansas City16.41%2,918,282Miami32.92%
19869,026,863New York1,480,567Kansas City16.40%2,973,142Miami32.94%
19879,187,899New York1,506,144Kansas City16.39%3,007,685Montreal32.74%
19889,348,935New York1,531,721Kansas City16.38%3,037,574Montreal32.49%
19899,509,971New York1,557,298Kansas City16.38%3,067,463Montreal32.26%
19909,671,007New York1,582,875Kansas City16.37%3,097,353Montreal32.03%
19919,763,899New York1,602,194Kansas City16.41%3,127,242Montreal32.03%
19929,856,792New York1,621,512Kansas City16.45%3,190,400Atlanta32.37%
19939,949,684New York1,631,900Milwaukee16.40%3,206,924Montreal32.23%
199410,042,577New York1,640,139Milwaukee16.33%3,246,765Montreal32.33%
199510,135,470New York1,648,378Milwaukee16.26%3,286,606Montreal32.43%
199610,228,362New York1,656,616Milwaukee16.20%3,326,447Montreal32.52%
199710,321,255New York1,664,855Milwaukee16.13%3,379,430Seattle32.74%
199810,414,147New York1,673,094Milwaukee16.07%3,366,408Montreal32.33%
199910,507,040New York1,681,333Milwaukee16.00%3,386,389Montreal32.23%
200010,599,933New York1,689,572Milwaukee15.94%3,406,369Montreal32.14%
200110,692,825New York1,697,811Milwaukee15.88%3,426,350Montreal32.04%
200210,785,718New York1,706,050Milwaukee15.82%3,454,555Phoenix32.03%
200310,878,610New York1,714,289Milwaukee15.76%3,555,895Phoenix32.69%
Avg14.94%34.60%

To be continued…

Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.