Baseball Toaster Mike's Baseball Rants
Help
This is my site with my opinions, but I hope that, like Irish Spring, you like it, too.
Frozen Toast
Search
Google Search
Web
Toaster
Mike's Baseball Rants
Archives

2009
01 

2008
10  09  07 
06  05  04  03 

2007
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2006
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2005
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2004
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2003
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2002
12  11  10  09  08  07 
Links to MBBR
Sopranos Whacks Phillies
2007-06-11 10:33
by Mike Carminati

Picture this scene: Pat Gillick, Dave Montgomery, and Charlie Manuel are sitting in a typical neighborhood dinner and in walks Jose Mesa. Fade to black…

Yeah it sucks as bad as the series end to the Sopranos—why do we care that Meadow can't park? And did we need ten seconds of blank screen? It's a highly artistic way to play out an intellectual dead end or, worse yet, a copout to leave the door open for a movie sequel (Yeah, screw you, too, David Chase!)

Anyway, a day after John Lieber shut out the lowly Royals, the Phils were slammed 17-5 by the worst offense in baseball. This team is so bad that Mark Grudzielanek is their best batter, going three for five with a home run, double, and five RBI from the three hole in the lineup.

What was even worse was that the Phils crawled back into the game after the newly floundering Jamie Moyer was driven out of the game after 3.2 innings and six runs. In the middle of the sixth, after home runs by Shane Victorino and Ryan Howard, the score stood at 6-5. Of course, Joe Table was on the mound…fade to black…

The seventeen run barrage was just the 62nd time in baseball history that a team followed up a shutout by allowing 17 or more runs. The worst was a 26-8 drubbing of the 1944 Dodgers at the hands of the Giants on April 20 a day after a 5-0 shutout. Here are the only times that a team allowed twenty runs after a shutout:

TeamLgYrShutout DateOppRRAWinnerNext GameOppRRAWLPCT
Brooklyn DodgersNL194419440429NY150Curt Davis19440430NY18266391.409
Baltimore OriolesAA188918890712KC240 18890713SL45257065.519
Chicago White StockingsNA187518750608BS120 18750612BS17243037.448
Cincinnati RedsNL191219120425PIT10 19120427PIT4237578.490
Toronto Blue JaysAL200020000927BAL40Frank Castillo20000928BAL1238379.512
Brooklyn RobinsNL191819180727SLN20 19180727SLN7225769.452
Cincinnati RedsNL191219120604BRO20 19120605NY110227578.490
Philadelphia PhilliesNL197919790516CHN130Steve Carlton19790517CHN23228478.519
Philadelphia QuakersNL188318830614BFN20 18830615BFN4221781.173
Cincinnati RedsNL189618960916PIT40 18960919CL42217750.606
Cleveland IndiansAL192119210924NYA90George Uhle19210925NYA7219460.610
Texas RangersAL199919990822BOS60Aaron Sele19990823NYA3219567.586
Boston Red SoxAL198019800619SEA20Bob Stanley19800620CAL2208377.519
Boston Red StockingsNA187118710621FW1210 18710626PH18202010.667
Detroit TigersAL192519250821WS110Earl Whitehill19250822WS15208173.526
Los Angeles DodgersNL196719670519CHN80Don Drysdale19670520CHN3207389.451
Philadelphia PhilliesNL191019101003BRO120 19101006BSN7207875.510
St. Louis BrownsNL189418940818BRO40 18940820BRO4205676.424
St. Louis CardinalsNL192319230510PHI70Bill Doak19230511PHI14207974.516
Washington NationalsNL188618860527CHN70 18860528CHN0202892.233

Meanwhile, Mesa came into town with a 12.34 ERA and proceeded to see the ERA and raise it to 12.46 (13.50 in 1.1 innings for the Phils). He has not had an ERA under 10.00 this entire season—his low was 10.13 on May 22 and May 28.

Mesa can become just the 22nd player ever to register a 10.00+ ERA with two separated teams in one season. If he keeps his Phils ERA over 12.34—yes, a Herculean task but if anyone can, he can do it—he will be just the 13th to take a 10.00+ ERA from one team and see his stratospheric ERA rise with his second team and the first since Dennys Reyes upped his 10.45 Pirate ERA with an 11.57 in Arizona in 2003:

PlayerYrTm1WLIP ERA Tm2WLIP ERA
Jose Mesa2007DET11 13.0 12.34 PHI00 1.3 13.50
Dennys Reyes2003PIT00 10.3 10.45 ARI00 2.3 11.57
David Moraga2000MON00 1.7 37.80 COL00 1.0 45.00
Mel Rojas1999LAN00 5.0 12.60 DET00 6.3 22.74
Mel Rojas1999LAN00 5.0 12.60 MON00 2.7 16.88
Kevin Jarvis1997CIN01 13.3 10.12 MIN00 13.0 12.46
John Roper1995CIN00 7.0 10.29 SFN00 1.0 27.00
Dale Murray1985NYA00 2.0 13.50 TEX00 1.0 18.00
Jackie Collum1962MIN02 15.3 11.15 CLE00 1.3 13.50
Ted Gray1955CHA00 3.0 18.00 CLE00 2.0 18.00
Ox Miller1943WS100 6.0 10.50 SLA00 6.0 12.00
Alex Ferguson1929PHI12 12.7 12.08 BRO01 2.0 22.50
Tony Kaufmann1927PHI03 18.7 10.61 SLN00 0.3 81.00
Bumpus Jones1893CIN13 28.7 10.05 NY101 4.0 11.25

Meanwhile, the Phils again lose a series after sweeping a division opponent on the road. Last time it was the Braves, now it's the Mets. Keep in mind that the Mets were missing two-thirds of the outfield. But still losing two of three to the Royals.The Phils may be a .500 or better team in the NL but it seems the are not much better than the lower echelon of AL teams, and the interleague record so far bears that out.

The AL is pounding the NL again this year to the tune of a .607 winning percentage (51 games to 33). Last year, the disparity was just as big, The AL won 154 against 98 losses, or a .611 winning percentage. Overall the AL leads in interleague play 1301 to 1235, .513. The NL hasn't won the season series since 2003. Here are the yearly breakdowns:

YrLgOpp LgWLPCT
1997ALNL97117.453
1998ALNL114110.509
1999ALNL116135.462
2000ALNL136115.542
2001ALNL132120.524
2002ALNL123129.488
2003ALNL115137.456
2004ALNL127125.504
2005ALNL136116.540
2006ALNL15498.611

Unfortunately, the Sopranos season is done but the Phils' isn't. With Freddy Garcia, who had struggled all year, finally succumbing to injuries and no viable replacement in the farm system; a decimated, Mesa-infused bullpen; no third baseman; Ryan still struggling—four Ks to go with the home run yesterday; Pat Burrell recreating his execrable 2003 season after being non-traded this past offseason, this team seems more likely to slide below .500 rather than keep their collective heads ever so slightly above it. Unlike Steve Perry, I am ready to stop believing.

Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.