Baseball Toaster Mike's Baseball Rants
Help
This is my site with my opinions, but I hope that, like Irish Spring, you like it, too.
Frozen Toast
Search
Google Search
Web
Toaster
Mike's Baseball Rants
Archives

2009
01 

2008
10  09  07 
06  05  04  03 

2007
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2006
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2005
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2004
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2003
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2002
12  11  10  09  08  07 
Links to MBBR
300! (Based on Rick Sutcliffe’s graphic novel)
2007-08-03 11:50
by Mike Carminati

July 31, 2007 was destined to become an historic date in baseball history. Barry Bonds was poised to tie the all-time career home run record. Alex Rodriguez was about to become the 22nd member of the 500-home run club. It would be just the fourth time in baseball history that two men hit their 500th in the same year (Frank Thomas did it earlier this season). Finally, Tom Glavine would reach the 300th win milestone, becoming the 23rd man to do so and would simultaneously win ten games for the 18th time, a feat only eight other pitchers have done (see below).

It's three days later and what have got? Nothin'! Bubkis! Nada. Zip. Zilch. The big goose egg.

Even the reinvigorated Bud Selig has given up on Bonds. The Yankees have hit fifteen homers in three games but none by A-Rod. Glavine came the closest to reaching his milestones, but the Mets bullpen lost his lead and then the game in the thirteenth. Maybe Bonds and A-Rod are waiting for Glavine's next start (Sunday) to try the trifecta again.

Anyway, the day of the big non-event I heard Rick Stutcliffe (or was it John Kruk—I think all of the ESPN non-personalities share one brain, albeit a reptilian one) opining that Glavine when he reaches 300 wins will become the last man to ever do so. This is the same speech that we have heard each time Clemens, Maddux, et al reached three hundred. Heck, they probably said it when Cy Young hit 300 wins, and he had 211 left in the tank.

I thought I would take a look at the previous 300-game winners to see whether any current players are on track for 300. Some may be right on pace with the legends and we don't even know it.

The only problem is that even with Glavine thrown in the nineteenth-century guys predominate. Even Glavine lags behind when we use the overall average for all 300-game winners. Here are the only players that match the pace for future 300-game winners at their age (through 2006). Two have already accomplished the feat:

PitcherW to 2006L to 2006AgeYrsFirstLast W by Age W by Age Since 1900 Min W by Age
Roger Clemens348178432319842006 340.00 321.78 257
Greg Maddux333203402219862006 307.73 297.07 218
C.C. Sabathia815625620012006 71.82 56.73 0
Felix Hernandez161820220052006 14.71 10.25 0

Ignoring the players who started pitching in the nineteenth century, you get an even dozen on track for 300 wins:

PitcherW to 2006L to 2006AgeYrsFirstLast W by Age W by Age Since 1900 Min W by Age
Roger Clemens348178432319842006 340.00 321.78 257
Greg Maddux333203402219862006 307.73 297.07 218
C.C. Sabathia815625620012006 71.82 56.73 0
Felix Hernandez161820220052006 14.71 10.25 0
Mark Buehrle976627720002006 118.65 94.63 6
Jon Garland826826720002006 93.13 73.19 2
Carlos Zambrano644225620012006 71.82 56.73 0
Dontrelle Willis583924420032006 66.17 54.25 4
Jake Peavy574525520022006 71.82 56.73 0
Jeremy Bonderman455323420032006 46.82 39.64 3
Matt Cain151321220052006 18.42 10.90 0
Tom Glavine290191402019872006 307.73 297.07 218

That seems like quite enough to rebuke Mssr. Sutcliffe, but I'll go one better. What if we look at those players that exceed the minimum wins that any 300-game winner amassed at the same age?

Well, then 259 including the likes of Dustin Nippert, who had one win by age 25. I list here just the ones with 100 or more wins (through 2006):

PitcherW to 2006L to 2006AgeYrsFirstLast W by Age W by Age Since 1900 Min W by Age
Roger Clemens348178432319842006 340.00 321.78 257
Greg Maddux333203402219862006 307.73 297.07 218
C.C. Sabathia815625620012006 71.82 56.73 0
Felix Hernandez161820220052006 14.71 10.25 0
Mark Buehrle976627720002006 118.65 94.63 6
Jon Garland826826720002006 93.13 73.19 2
Carlos Zambrano644225620012006 71.82 56.73 0
Dontrelle Willis583924420032006 66.17 54.25 4
Jake Peavy574525520022006 71.82 56.73 0
Jeremy Bonderman455323420032006 46.82 39.64 3
Matt Cain151321220052006 18.42 10.90 0
Tom Glavine290191402019872006 307.73 297.07 218
Randy Johnson280147422119882006 333.60 315.44 240
Mike Mussina239134371619912006 271.25 262.33 162
Curt Schilling207138392019882006 300.88 291.87 197
Pedro Martinez20692341519922006 245.19 221.38 110
Andy Pettitte186104341219952006 245.19 221.38 110
Brad Radke148139331219952006 223.75 205.63 97
Aaron Sele145110361419932006 268.21 247.00 145
Bartolo Colon14087331119972006 223.75 205.63 97
Steve Trachsel134143351519932006 262.95 238.50 130
Jason Schmidt12790331419952006 223.75 205.63 97
Esteban Loaiza123108341519952006 245.19 221.38 110
Livan Hernandez123117311319962006 204.26 169.56 66
Kevin Millwood12387311019972006 204.26 169.56 66
Tim Hudson1196030819992006 185.74 152.31 54
Freddy Garcia1167131919992006 204.26 169.56 66
Chan Ho Park11387331419942006 223.75 205.63 97
Matt Morris1117731919972006 204.26 169.56 66
Russ Ortiz10879321019982006 216.59 187.50 81
Jeff Suppan106101311419952006 204.26 169.56 66
Mark Mulder1035728720002006 140.87 113.19 17
Barry Zito1026328720002006 140.87 113.19 17
Chris Carpenter1006831919972006 204.26 169.56 66
Javier Vazquez10010529919982006 164.52 132.25 31
Derek Lowe10082331119972006 223.75 205.63 97

My point is that if you take a look around, there are plenty of candidates for 300 wins. Most probably very few of them will reach the magical number, but they seem as likely as most of the 300-game winners at various stages in their careers.

For the record, average by age for all 300-game winners (plus Glavine):
AgeTot WNum Players W by Age W by Age Since 1900 Min W by Age
1841 4.00 0.00 4
1954 1.25 1.25 0
201037 14.71 10.25 0
2122112 18.42 10.90 0
2246614 33.29 25.30 9
2379617 46.82 39.64 3
24119118 66.17 54.25 4
25158022 71.82 56.73 0
26214223 93.13 73.19 2
27272923 118.65 94.63 6
28324023 140.87 113.19 17
29378423 164.52 132.25 31
30427223 185.74 152.31 54
31469823 204.26 169.56 66
32476522 216.59 187.50 81
33447520 223.75 205.63 97
34514921 245.19 221.38 110
35552221 262.95 238.50 130
36509619 268.21 247.00 145
37434016 271.25 262.33 162
38457216 285.75 276.60 178
39481416 300.88 291.87 197
40461615 307.73 297.07 218
41415413 319.54 306.33 233
42333610 333.60 315.44 240
43340010 340.00 321.78 257
4417705 354.00 314.75 268
456032 301.50 301.50 284
466242 312.00 312.00 300
473111 311.00 311.00 311
483181 318.00 318.00 318

And here are the pitchers with at least 18 years of ten or more wins:

Pitcher#Yrs 10+ W
Don Sutton21
Nolan Ryan20
Phil Niekro19
Roger Clemens19
Greg Maddux19
Cy Young19
Walter Johnson18
Steve Carlton18
Comments
2007-08-03 14:46:29
1.   daryl
I think this is an interesting topic. I have heard the same thing from radio talk show guys, that there will not be another 300 game winner. I believe there will be 300 game winners still to come. Obviously, good health along with being an outstanding pitcher are what is needed. The radio guy said that few pitchers will reach 600 starts, the number he saw as being the minimum need to reach 300 wins. Well, here are my guesses on who can reach it.

First Randy Johnson still has a real shot at it if he can return from this last surgery.

Next I would say Pedro & Pettitte still have outside shots at it. Pedro at 206 wins age 35 & Pettitte at 193 age 35. If they play to 42 with good health, that would be 7 years. An average of 14 wins a season would get it done, this is close to what Maddux & Glavine did in this age range. Health of Pedro & Pettitte makes this unlikely, but I don't feel impossible.

My next 10 are further away, 7 made your list also.

Zito 110 wins, 244 starts 29 age
Buehrle 105 wins, 250 starts, 28 age
Garland 90 wins, 213 starts, 27 age
Sabathia 94 wins, 208 starts, 26 age
Mulder 103 wins, 199 starts, 29 age
Zambrano 78 wins, 169 starts, 26 age
Hudson 130 wins, 270 starts, 31 age

The 3 additional I added are:

Santana 89 wins, 164 starts, 28 age
Lackey 73 wins, 171 starts, 28 age
Halladay 106 wins, 211 starts, 30 age

There are other names that I just think it is still too early to put in a list, Peavy, Willis, Bonderman & F Hernandez.

I don't know about your statement that a few will make it, but I would think of the 13 I mentioned at least 1 will make it and maybe a couple more. I don't think 300 wins is an unattainable number.

2007-08-04 01:29:23
2.   snydes
I didn't see Roy Oswalt. He's almost a year younger than Halladay with a couple more wins. He didn't have the required 100 wins by last year but he seems a better bet than a lot of guys on that list, too (Park, Ortiz, Suppan and bunch of others).

Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.