Baseball Toaster Mike's Baseball Rants
Help
This is my site with my opinions, but I hope that, like Irish Spring, you like it, too.
Frozen Toast
Search
Google Search
Web
Toaster
Mike's Baseball Rants
Archives

2009
01 

2008
10  09  07 
06  05  04  03 

2007
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2006
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2005
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2004
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2003
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2002
12  11  10  09  08  07 
Links to MBBR
The Real Reason to Hate Interleague Play
2006-08-09 19:41
by Mike Carminati

One can complain about the unbalanced schedule or the inelegance of using the designated hitter only in American League parks, but the real reason to hate interleague play is how it affects what are annually becoming closer and closer races, especially in the wild card hunt.

I looked into this last year and found that ten playoff spots in ten years were altered by the results of these legitimized exhibitions. With the AL again dominating the senior circuit in interleague play, the ultra-tight NL West and wild card races have been turned inside out by interleague results.

The NL wild card has ten clubs separated by six games (as of about 9 PM tonight) and the NL West sees all five clubs within 4.5 games of each other. Take away the interleague games and each races gets tighter at the top even though more teams would drop from contention

Let's take a look. First, here are the current (ish) standings:

AL EastWLPCTGB
New York6643.606-
Boston6546.5862
Toronto6054.5268.5
Baltimore5164.44318
Tampa Bay4768.40922
AL CentralWLPCTGB
Detroit7637.673-
Chicago6645.5959
Minnesota6646.5899.5
Cleveland4764.42328
Kansas City3973.34836.5
AL WestWLPCTGB
Oakland6252.544-
Los Angeles5954.5222.5
Texas5758.4965.5
Seattle5657.4965.5
AL Wild CardWLPCTGB
Chicago6645.595-
Minnesota6646.5890.5
Boston6546.5861
Toronto6054.5267.5
Los Angeles5954.5228
Texas5758.49611
Seattle5657.49611
Baltimore5164.44317
Cleveland4764.42319
Tampa Bay4768.40921
Kansas City3973.34827.5
NL EastWLPCTGB
New York6744.604-
Philadelphia5558.48713
Florida5260.46415.5
Atlanta5261.46016
Washington4963.43818.5
NL CentralWLPCTGB
St. Louis6151.545-
Cincinnati5855.5133.5
Houston5458.4827
Milwaukee5260.4649
Chicago4864.42913
Pittsburgh4271.37219.5
NL WestWLPCTGB
San Diego5854.518-
Los Angeles5855.5130.5
Arizona5756.5041.5
Colorado5458.4824
San Francisco5459.4784.5
NL Wild CardWLPCTGB
Cincinnati5855.513-
Los Angeles5855.513-
Arizona5756.5041
Philadelphia5558.4873
Houston5458.4823.5
Colorado5458.4823.5
San Francisco5459.4784
Florida5260.4645.5
Milwaukee5260.4645.5
Atlanta5261.4606
Washington4963.4388.5
Chicago4864.4299.5
Pittsburgh4271.37216

Here are the interleague standings. Note that the AL won more than 61% of the games. That's dominance:

ALWLPCTGB
Boston162.889-
Minnesota162.889-
Detroit153.8331
Chicago144.7782
Seattle144.7782
Tampa Bay117.6115
New York108.5566
Kansas City108.5566
Toronto99.5007
Baltimore99.5007
Cleveland810.4448
Oakland810.4448
Los Angeles711.3899
Texas711.3899
Total15498.611
NLWLPCTGB
Colorado114.733-
San Francisco87.5333
Florida99.5003.5
San Diego78.4674
New York69.4005
Cincinnati69.4005
Milwaukee69.4005
Washington711.3895.5
Houston711.3895.5
Atlanta510.3336
St. Louis510.3336
Los Angeles510.3336
Philadelphia513.2787.5
Chicago411.2677
Arizona411.2677
Pittsburgh312.2008
Total98154.389

Finally, here are the standings as they would appear without the execrable interleague play:

AL EastWLPCTGB
New York5635.615-
Toronto5145.5317.5
Boston4944.5278
Baltimore4255.43317
Tampa Bay3661.37123
AL Central
Detroit6134.642-
Chicago5241.5598
Minnesota5044.53210.5
Cleveland3954.41921
Kansas City2965.30931.5
AL West
Oakland5442.563-
Los Angeles5243.5471.5
Texas5047.5154.5
Seattle4253.44211.5
AL Wild CardWLPCTGB
Chicago5241.559-
Los Angeles5243.5471
Toronto5145.5312.5
Minnesota5044.5322.5
Boston4944.5273
Texas5047.5154
Seattle4253.44211
Baltimore4255.43312
Cleveland3954.41913
Tampa Bay3661.37118
Kansas City2965.30923.5
NL East
New York6135.635-
Philadelphia5045.52610.5
Atlanta4751.48015
Florida4351.45717
Washington4252.44718
NL Central
St. Louis5641.577-
Cincinnati5246.5314.5
Houston4747.5007.5
Milwaukee4651.47410
Chicago4453.45412
Pittsburgh3959.39817.5
NL West
Los Angeles5345.541-
Arizona5345.541-
San Diego5146.5261.5
San Francisco4652.4697
Colorado4354.4439.5
NL Wild CardWLPCTGB
Los Angeles5345.541-
Arizona5345.541-
Cincinnati5246.5311
Philadelphia5045.5261.5
San Diego5146.5261.5
Houston4747.5004
Atlanta4751.4806
Milwaukee4651.4746.5
San Francisco4652.4697
Florida4351.4578
Chicago4453.4548.5
Washington4252.4479
Colorado4354.4439.5
Pittsburgh3959.39814

One result that I didn't expect is that the Yankees would be running away with the AL East crown instead of holding a small lead over the Red Sox. I also didn't realize that the Angels would end up right in the middle of the wild card chase.

In the NL, the Dodgers and D-Backs, instead of the Padres, would own the NL West. The Padres and Reds would lose their playoff leads. A number of teams would drop from the wild card hunt, but the top four spots would be within a game and one half of each other.

Wake me up when the AL is winning 90% of the interleague contests, the NL wild card winner is under .500 and all but the truly awful NL teams are in the wild card hunt. It makes about as much sense as the Phils trading both their long relievers from both sides to the team they are chasing in the wild card race, the Reds. Then again, trading their crappy pitchers to the "enemy" might be the most strategic thing this club has done since trading Jim Thome.

Comments
2006-08-09 21:53:49
1.   Yu-Hsing Chen
Boston had that 13 game winning streak bullshite during the interleague play, which was the main reason why they had a lead on the division for the late part of the first half.

I agree that they should at the very least lower interleague play (And division plays too.. yes you should play your division more but not THAT much more)

Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.