Baseball Toaster Mike's Baseball Rants
Help
This is my site with my opinions, but I hope that, like Irish Spring, you like it, too.
Frozen Toast
Search
Google Search
Web
Toaster
Mike's Baseball Rants
Archives

2009
01 

2008
10  09  07 
06  05  04  03 

2007
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2006
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2005
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2004
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2003
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2002
12  11  10  09  08  07 
Links to MBBR
In First (And Last) to Last
2006-07-31 21:51
by Mike Carminati

I have been compiling a plethora of information based on Retrosheet data, and tonight I ran into some interesting results. Given that I never met a table I didn't like, I hereby present the all-time leaders in percent of regular season days spent in first place:

FranchiseLg% in 1st% Last
New York YankeesAL34.20%4.17%
Arizona DiamondbacksNL33.96%23.98%
San Francisco GiantsNL23.32%6.74%
Los Angeles DodgersNL21.30%5.12%
Oakland AthleticsAL18.79%20.40%
St. Louis CardinalsNL18.26%7.85%
Atlanta BravesNL17.69%12.46%
Los Angeles Angels of AnaheimAL16.73%12.30%
Seattle MarinersAL16.67%25.22%
Houston AstrosNL16.63%10.83%

And here are the all-time worst:

FranchiseLg% in 1st% Last
Tampa Bay Devil RaysAL1.66%73.32%
Florida MarlinsNL6.93%24.13%
Milwaukee BrewersNL7.27%20.07%
Colorado RockiesNL7.94%26.86%
Washington NationalsNL9.22%18.40%
Philadelphia PhilliesNL9.78%21.91%
Minnesota TwinsAL10.90%13.16%
New York MetsNL11.17%25.67%
Baltimore OriolesAL11.56%16.34%
San Diego PadresNL11.78%33.91%

No surprises in the leaders (the Yankees and Tampa Bay, who have spent a grand total of 24 days in first place) on those lists. However, the all-time best among defunct clubs, the American Association's Boston Reds, who spent over 83% of their time in first, would not be the first club one thinks of. (By the way, 25 defunct clubs have spent not one day in first, tying for the all-time worst.)

Now for the least amount of time in last place in whatever division or league configuration that prevailed at the time:

FranchiseLg% in 1st% Last
New York YankeesAL34.20%4.17%
Los Angeles DodgersNL21.30%5.12%
San Francisco GiantsNL23.32%6.74%
St. Louis CardinalsNL18.26%7.85%
Chicago White SoxAL13.86%7.94%
Chicago CubsNL15.65%8.88%
Cincinnati RedsNL13.39%9.90%
Cleveland IndiansAL14.39%10.19%
Houston AstrosNL16.63%10.83%
Boston Red SoxAL15.27%11.26%

Now, the teams that spent the most time in last place:

FranchiseLg% in 1st% Last
Tampa Bay Devil RaysAL1.66%73.32%
San Diego PadresNL11.78%33.91%
Colorado RockiesNL7.94%26.86%
New York MetsNL11.17%25.67%
Texas RangersAL12.04%25.48%
Seattle MarinersAL16.67%25.22%
Florida MarlinsNL6.93%24.13%
Arizona DiamondbacksNL33.96%23.98%
Toronto Blue JaysAL16.41%22.71%
Philadelphia PhilliesNL9.78%21.91%

To get a truer picture, let's look at the ratio of days in first to days in last:

FranchiseLg% in 1st% LastFirst-Last Ratio
New York YankeesAL34.20%4.17%8.19
Los Angeles DodgersNL21.30%5.12%4.16
San Francisco GiantsNL23.32%6.74%3.46
St. Louis CardinalsNL18.26%7.85%2.32
Chicago CubsNL15.65%8.88%1.76
Chicago White SoxAL13.86%7.94%1.75
Houston AstrosNL16.63%10.83%1.54
Atlanta BravesNL17.69%12.46%1.42
Arizona DiamondbacksNL33.96%23.98%1.42
Cleveland IndiansAL14.39%10.19%1.41

Now the worst ratios:

FranchiseLg% in 1st% LastFirst-Last Ratio
Tampa Bay Devil RaysAL1.66%73.32%0.02
Florida MarlinsNL6.93%24.13%0.29
Colorado RockiesNL7.94%26.86%0.30
San Diego PadresNL11.78%33.91%0.35
Milwaukee BrewersNL7.27%20.07%0.36
New York MetsNL11.17%25.67%0.43
Philadelphia PhilliesNL9.78%21.91%0.45
Texas RangersAL12.04%25.48%0.47
Washington NationalsNL9.22%18.40%0.50
Seattle MarinersAL16.67%25.22%0.66

Of course, the Phillies are the worst of the original 16 teams.

As for the average position for each teams, here are the best (not that expansion teams get a boost from being in smaller groupings):

FranchiseLg POS Avg
Arizona DiamondbacksNL 2.64
New York YankeesAL 2.93
San Francisco GiantsNL 3.38
Kansas City RoyalsAL 3.46
Washington NationalsNL 3.53
Florida MarlinsNL 3.64
Toronto Blue JaysAL 3.69
Colorado RockiesNL 3.72
Los Angeles Angels of AnaheimAL 3.74
Los Angeles DodgersNL 3.77

Now the worst average position teams:

FranchiseLg POS Avg
Philadelphia PhilliesNL 4.78
Baltimore OriolesAL 4.67
Tampa Bay Devil RaysAL 4.57
Minnesota TwinsAL 4.53
Texas RangersAL 4.43
Oakland AthleticsAL 4.41
New York MetsNL 4.35
Atlanta BravesNL 4.24
Cincinnati RedsNL 4.19
Milwaukee BrewersNL 4.14
Seattle MarinersAL 4.14
Pittsburgh PiratesNL 4.14

Ah, it makes one proud to be a Phillies fan. Will someone please contract my team and free me from this curse?

Comments
2006-08-01 02:33:13
1.   Voxter
The first four slots on the top ratios are almost exactly as I would have predicted them, except I would have expected the Cards to be ahead of the Giants.

I assume when you say "San Francisco Giants" or "Los Angeles Dodgers" you're including the time both teams spent in New York? Because my off-the-cuff imaginings tell me the San Francisco Giants have only been intermittently successful.

2006-08-01 18:22:43
2.   Mike Carminati
Correct, those are the franchise totals.

Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.