Baseball Toaster Mike's Baseball Rants
Help
This is my site with my opinions, but I hope that, like Irish Spring, you like it, too.
Frozen Toast
Search
Google Search
Web
Toaster
Mike's Baseball Rants
Archives

2009
01 

2008
10  09  07 
06  05  04  03 

2007
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2006
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2005
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2004
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2003
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2002
12  11  10  09  08  07 
Links to MBBR
The Long and the Short of It, III
2006-04-05 15:44
by Mike Carminati
Part I Part II

Now, here are the shortest possible (though unconfirmed) infields all time:

TmLgYr2BHTSSHT3BHT1BHTCHTTot HtAvgAvg Ft Avg In
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Tom Morrison63Frank Shannon63Doggie Miller66Herm McFarland6632464.85 4.8
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Frank Shannon63Tom Morrison63Doggie Miller66Herm McFarland6632464.85 4.8
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Frank Shannon63Tom Morrison63Doggie Miller66Charlie Dexter67325655 5.0
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Tom Morrison63Frank Shannon63Doggie Miller66Charlie Dexter67325655 5.0
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Frank Eustace69Frank Shannon63Tom Morrison63Doggie Miller66Herm McFarland6632765.45 5.4
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Frank Eustace69Tom Morrison63Frank Shannon63Doggie Miller66Herm McFarland6632765.45 5.4
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Jack Crooks70Frank Shannon63Tom Morrison63Doggie Miller66Herm McFarland6632865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Frank Eustace69Tom Morrison63Frank Shannon63Doggie Miller66Charlie Dexter6732865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Frank Eustace69Frank Shannon63Tom Morrison63Doggie Miller66Charlie Dexter6732865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Jack Crooks70Tom Morrison63Frank Shannon63Doggie Miller66Herm McFarland6632865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Frank Shannon63Tom Morrison63Pete Cassidy70Doggie Miller6632865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Frank Shannon63Tom Morrison63Tom Kinslow70Herm McFarland6632865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Doggie Miller66Frank Shannon63Tom Morrison63Tom Kinslow70Herm McFarland6632865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Frank Shannon63Tom Morrison63Pete Cassidy70Herm McFarland6632865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Doggie Miller66Tom Morrison63Frank Shannon63Pete Cassidy70Herm McFarland6632865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Doggie Miller66Frank Shannon63Tom Morrison63Pete Cassidy70Herm McFarland6632865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Tom Morrison63Frank Shannon63Tom Kinslow70Doggie Miller6632865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Tom Morrison63Frank Shannon63Tom Kinslow70Herm McFarland6632865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Tom Morrison63Frank Shannon63Pete Cassidy70Doggie Miller6632865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Doggie Miller66Tom Morrison63Frank Shannon63Tom Kinslow70Herm McFarland6632865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Tom Morrison63Frank Shannon63Doggie Miller66Tom Kinslow7032865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Frank Shannon63Tom Morrison63Doggie Miller66Tom Kinslow7032865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Tom Morrison63Frank Shannon63Doggie Miller66Lawrence Freund7032865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Frank Shannon63Tom Morrison63Doggie Miller66Lawrence Freund7032865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Frank Shannon63Tom Morrison63Tom Kinslow70Doggie Miller6632865.65 5.6
Louisville ColonelsNL1896Ducky Holmes66Tom Morrison63Frank Shannon63Pete Cassidy70Herm McFarland6632865.65 5.6

The shortest possible infields since 1900:

TmLgYr2BHTSSHT3BHT1BHTCHTTot HtAvgAvg Ft Avg In
Washington SenatorsAL1903Ducky Holmes66Rabbit Robinson66Kip Selbach67Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733266.45 6.4
Washington SenatorsAL1903Ducky Holmes66Champ Osteen68Rabbit Robinson66Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733366.65 6.6
Washington SenatorsAL1903Rabbit Robinson66Champ Osteen68Ducky Holmes66Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733366.65 6.6
Washington SenatorsAL1903Rabbit Robinson66Gene DeMontreville68Ducky Holmes66Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733366.65 6.6
Washington SenatorsAL1903Ducky Holmes66Gene DeMontreville68Rabbit Robinson66Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733366.65 6.6
Washington SenatorsAL1903Gene DeMontreville68Rabbit Robinson66Ducky Holmes66Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733366.65 6.6
Washington SenatorsAL1903Rabbit Robinson66Champ Osteen68Kip Selbach67Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733466.85 6.8
Washington SenatorsAL1903Rabbit Robinson66Bill Coughlin69Ducky Holmes66Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733466.85 6.8
Washington SenatorsAL1903Ducky Holmes66Bill Coughlin69Rabbit Robinson66Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733466.85 6.8
Washington SenatorsAL1903Bill Coughlin69Rabbit Robinson66Ducky Holmes66Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733466.85 6.8
Washington SenatorsAL1903Ducky Holmes66Rabbit Robinson66Bill Coughlin69Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733466.85 6.8
Washington SenatorsAL1903Rabbit Robinson66Gene DeMontreville68Kip Selbach67Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733466.85 6.8
Washington SenatorsAL1903Ducky Holmes66Champ Osteen68Kip Selbach67Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733466.85 6.8
Washington SenatorsAL1903Ducky Holmes66Gene DeMontreville68Kip Selbach67Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733466.85 6.8
Washington SenatorsAL1903Barry McCormick69Rabbit Robinson66Ducky Holmes66Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733466.85 6.8
Washington SenatorsAL1903Gene DeMontreville68Rabbit Robinson66Kip Selbach67Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge6733466.85 6.8
Washington SenatorsAL1903Barry McCormick69Rabbit Robinson66Kip Selbach67Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge67335675 7.0
Washington SenatorsAL1903Gene DeMontreville68Champ Osteen68Rabbit Robinson66Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge67335675 7.0
Washington SenatorsAL1903Gene DeMontreville68Champ Osteen68Ducky Holmes66Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge67335675 7.0
Washington SenatorsAL1903Rabbit Robinson66Bill Coughlin69Kip Selbach67Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge67335675 7.0
Washington SenatorsAL1903Ducky Holmes66Bill Coughlin69Kip Selbach67Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge67335675 7.0
Washington SenatorsAL1903Bill Coughlin69Rabbit Robinson66Kip Selbach67Lew Drill66Malachi Kittridge67335675 7.0
Detroit TigersAL1904Rabbit Robinson66Charley O'Leary67Bill Coughlin69Lew Drill66Frank McManus67335675 7.0
Baltimore OriolesAL1902Harry Howell69Billy Gilbert64John McGraw67Lew Drill66Roger Bresnahan69335675 7.0
Baltimore OriolesAL1902Jimmy Williams69Billy Gilbert64John McGraw67Lew Drill66Roger Bresnahan69335675 7.0
Baltimore OriolesAL1902Jimmy Williams69Billy Gilbert64John McGraw67Harry Howell69Lew Drill66335675 7.0
Baltimore OriolesAL1902Harry Howell69Billy Gilbert64John McGraw67Jimmy Williams69Lew Drill66335675 7.0

The shortest possible since 1950:

Yr2BHTSSHT3BHT1BHTCHTTot HtAvgAvg Ft Avg In
1999Chad Fonville66Jeff Frye69Donnie Sadler66Lou Merloni70Lenny Webster69340685 8.0
1999Chad Fonville66Donnie Sadler66Jeff Frye69Lou Merloni70Lenny Webster69340685 8.0
1965Joe Morgan67Sonny Jackson69Mike White68Nellie Fox69Ron Brand6834168.25 8.2
1965Joe Morgan67Sonny Jackson69Mike White68Chuck Harrison70Ron Brand6834268.45 8.4
1966Joe Morgan67Sonny Jackson69Ron Brand68Chuck Harrison70Bill Heath6834268.45 8.4
1963Joe Morgan67Jimmy Wynn69Ernie Fazio67Carl Warwick70Jerry Grote7034368.65 8.6
1963Joe Morgan67Sonny Jackson69Ernie Fazio67Carl Warwick70Jerry Grote7034368.65 8.6
1950Billy Cox70Bobby Morgan69Pee Wee Reese69Bruce Edwards67Roy Campanella6834368.65 8.6
1950Billy Cox70Pee Wee Reese69Bobby Morgan69Bruce Edwards67Roy Campanella6834368.65 8.6
1950Billy Cox70Bobby Morgan69Spider Jorgensen69Bruce Edwards67Roy Campanella6834368.65 8.6
1963Joe Morgan67Ernie Fazio67Jimmy Wynn69Carl Warwick70Jerry Grote7034368.65 8.6
1965Joe Morgan67Sonny Jackson69Nellie Fox69Chuck Harrison70Ron Brand6834368.65 8.6
1965Joe Morgan67Bob Lillis71Mike White68Nellie Fox69Ron Brand6834368.65 8.6
1950Billy Cox70Pee Wee Reese69Spider Jorgensen69Bruce Edwards67Roy Campanella6834368.65 8.6
1958Johnny Schaive68Rocky Bridges68Bobby Malkmus69Eddie Yost70Clint Courtney6834368.65 8.6
1958Johnny Schaive68Bobby Malkmus69Rocky Bridges68Eddie Yost70Clint Courtney6834368.65 8.6
1953Johnny O'Brien69Dick Smith68Eddie Pellagrini69Paul Smith68Vic Janowicz6934368.65 8.6

Here are the tallest possible infields of all time:

TmLgYr2BHTSSHT3BHT1BHTCHTTot HtAvgAvg Ft Avg In
Cleveland IndiansAL1998Jeff Manto75Travis Fryman73Russell Branyan75Richie Sexson80Sandy Alomar77380766 4.0
Cleveland IndiansAL1998Jeff Manto75Shawon Dunston73Russell Branyan75Richie Sexson80Sandy Alomar77380766 4.0
Cleveland IndiansAL1998Jeff Manto75Travis Fryman73Pat Borders74Richie Sexson80Sandy Alomar7737975.86 3.8
Cleveland IndiansAL1998Jeff Manto75Shawon Dunston73Pat Borders74Richie Sexson80Sandy Alomar7737975.86 3.8
Seattle MarinersAL2005Scott Spiezio74Mike Morse76Jose Lopez74Richie Sexson80Dan Wilson7537975.86 3.8
Seattle MarinersAL2005Jose Lopez74Mike Morse76Scott Spiezio74Richie Sexson80Dan Wilson7537975.86 3.8
Washington SenatorsAL1968Frank Coggins74Ken McMullen75Ron Hansen75Frank Howard79Paul Casanova7637975.86 3.8
Washington SenatorsAL1968Frank Coggins74Ken McMullen75Ron Hansen75Frank Howard79Billy Bryan7637975.86 3.8
Washington SenatorsAL1968Frank Coggins74Ron Hansen75Ken McMullen75Frank Howard79Billy Bryan7637975.86 3.8
Washington SenatorsAL1968Frank Coggins74Ron Hansen75Ken McMullen75Frank Howard79Paul Casanova7637975.86 3.8
Anaheim AngelsAL1999Tim Unroe75Jeff Huson75Troy Glaus77Matt Luke77Steve Decker7537975.86 3.8
California AngelsAL1995Rene Gonzales75Gary DiSarcina73Eduardo Perez76Carlos Martinez77Andy Allanson7737875.66 3.6
Cleveland IndiansAL1998Jeff Manto75Shawon Dunston73Travis Fryman73Richie Sexson80Sandy Alomar7737875.66 3.6
Cleveland IndiansAL1998Shawon Dunston73Travis Fryman73Jeff Manto75Richie Sexson80Sandy Alomar7737875.66 3.6
Cleveland IndiansAL1998Shawon Dunston73Travis Fryman73Russell Branyan75Richie Sexson80Sandy Alomar7737875.66 3.6
Seattle MarinersAL2005Jose Lopez74Mike Morse76Scott Spiezio74Richie Sexson80Miguel Ojeda7437875.66 3.6
Seattle MarinersAL2005Scott Spiezio74Mike Morse76Jose Lopez74Richie Sexson80Miguel Ojeda7437875.66 3.6
Seattle MarinersAL2005Scott Spiezio74Mike Morse76Greg Dobbs73Richie Sexson80Dan Wilson7537875.66 3.6
San Francisco GiantsNL1996Steve Scarsone74Matt Williams74Steve Decker75Desi Wilson79Marcus Jensen7637875.66 3.6
Seattle MarinersAL2005Jose Lopez74Mike Morse76Scott Spiezio74Richie Sexson80Pat Borders7437875.66 3.6
Seattle MarinersAL2005Scott Spiezio74Mike Morse76Jose Lopez74Richie Sexson80Pat Borders7437875.66 3.6
Seattle MarinersAL2005Jose Lopez74Mike Morse76Greg Dobbs73Richie Sexson80Dan Wilson7537875.66 3.6
Washington SenatorsAL1968Tim Cullen73Ron Hansen75Ken McMullen75Frank Howard79Paul Casanova7637875.66 3.6
Washington SenatorsAL1968Tim Cullen73Ken McMullen75Ron Hansen75Frank Howard79Billy Bryan7637875.66 3.6
Washington SenatorsAL1968Tim Cullen73Ron Hansen75Ken McMullen75Frank Howard79Billy Bryan7637875.66 3.6
Washington SenatorsAL1968Tim Cullen73Ken McMullen75Ron Hansen75Frank Howard79Paul Casanova7637875.66 3.6
Texas RangersAL1991Monty Fariss76Gary Green75Jeff Huson75Rob Maurer75Mark Parent7737875.66 3.6
Anaheim AngelsAL1999Jeff Huson75Andy Sheets74Troy Glaus77Matt Luke77Steve Decker7537875.66 3.6
Anaheim AngelsAL1999Tim Unroe75Jeff Huson75Troy Glaus77Matt Luke77Bret Hemphill7437875.66 3.6
Anaheim AngelsAL1999Tim Unroe75Jeff Huson75Troy Glaus77Matt Luke77Charlie O'Brien7437875.66 3.6
Anaheim AngelsAL1999Tim Unroe75Andy Sheets74Troy Glaus77Matt Luke77Steve Decker7537875.66 3.6
Anaheim AngelsAL1999Tim Unroe75Jeff Huson75Troy Glaus77Chris Pritchett76Steve Decker7537875.66 3.6
Anaheim AngelsAL1999Andy Sheets74Jeff Huson75Troy Glaus77Matt Luke77Steve Decker7537875.66 3.6

The tallest possible infields before 1950:

TmLgYr2BHTSSHT3BHT1BHTCHTTot HtAvgAvg Ft Avg In
Chicago White SoxAL1947Don Kolloway75Jack Wallaesa75Bob Kennedy74Jake Jones75Joe Stephenson7437374.66 2.6
Chicago White SoxAL1947Don Kolloway75Jack Wallaesa75Bob Kennedy74Jake Jones75George Dickey7437374.66 2.6
Chicago White SoxAL1946Don Kolloway75Frank Whitman74Bob Kennedy74Jake Jones75George Dickey7437274.46 2.4
Chicago White SoxAL1947Don Kolloway75Jack Wallaesa75Bob Kennedy74Rudy York73George Dickey7437174.26 2.2
Chicago White SoxAL1947Don Kolloway75Jack Wallaesa75Bob Kennedy74Rudy York73Joe Stephenson7437174.26 2.2
Chicago White SoxAL1946Don Kolloway75Frank Whitman74Bob Kennedy74Hal Trosky74George Dickey7437174.26 2.2
St. Louis CardinalsNL1942Harry Walker74Marty Marion74Erv Dusak74Ray Sanders74Walker Cooper7537174.26 2.2
New York GiantsNL1947Bobby Thomson74Buddy Kerr74Bill Rigney73Johnny Mize74Ernie Lombardi75370746 2.0
New York GiantsNL1947Bobby Thomson74Buddy Kerr74Bill Rigney73Johnny Mize74Walker Cooper75370746 2.0
Philadelphia PhilliesNL1941Stan Benjamin74Harry Marnie73Bill Nagel73Nick Etten74Bill Harman76370746 2.0
Philadelphia PhilliesNL1941Bill Nagel73Harry Marnie73Stan Benjamin74Nick Etten74Bill Harman76370746 2.0
St. Louis CardinalsNL1946Nippy Jones73Marty Marion74Erv Dusak74Dick Sisler74Del Wilber75370746 2.0
St. Louis CardinalsNL1946Nippy Jones73Marty Marion74Erv Dusak74Harry Walker74Del Wilber75370746 2.0
St. Louis CardinalsNL1947Nippy Jones73Marty Marion74Erv Dusak74Dick Sisler74Del Wilber75370746 2.0
St. Louis CardinalsNL1946Nippy Jones73Marty Marion74Erv Dusak74Dick Sisler74Del Rice7436973.86 1.8
New York GiantsNL1949Bill Rigney73Buddy Kerr74Monte Irvin73Johnny Mize74Walker Cooper7536973.86 1.8
St. Louis CardinalsNL1946Nippy Jones73Marty Marion74Erv Dusak74Harry Walker74Del Rice7436973.86 1.8
St. Louis CardinalsNL1947Nippy Jones73Marty Marion74Erv Dusak74Dick Sisler74Del Rice7436973.86 1.8
St. Louis CardinalsNL1948Erv Dusak74Marty Marion74Bobby Young73Nippy Jones73Del Wilber7536973.86 1.8
New York GiantsNL1947Bobby Thomson74Buddy Kerr74Bill Rigney73Johnny Mize74Bennie Warren7336873.66 1.6
St. Louis CardinalsNL1948Erv Dusak74Marty Marion74Bobby Young73Nippy Jones73Del Rice7436873.66 1.6
Philadelphia PhilliesNL1941Stan Benjamin74Harry Marnie73Bill Nagel73Nick Etten74Bennie Warren7336773.46 1.4
Philadelphia PhilliesNL1941Bill Nagel73Harry Marnie73Stan Benjamin74Nick Etten74Bennie Warren7336773.46 1.4

The tallest possible infields before 1900:

TmLgYr2BHTSSHT3BHT1BHTCHTTot HtAvgAvg Ft Avg In
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Sy Sutcliffe74Charlie Ganzel72Dan Brouthers74Deacon McGuire7337174.26 2.2
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Sy Sutcliffe74Deacon White71Dan Brouthers74Deacon McGuire73370746 2.0
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Sy Sutcliffe74Charlie Ganzel72Dan Brouthers74Jake Wells7136973.86 1.8
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Sy Sutcliffe74Charlie Ganzel72Dan Brouthers74Charlie Bennett7136973.86 1.8
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Sy Sutcliffe74Deacon White71Dan Brouthers74Charlie Ganzel7236973.86 1.8
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Charlie Ganzel72Deacon White71Dan Brouthers74Sy Sutcliffe7436973.86 1.8
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Sy Sutcliffe74Charlie Ganzel72Charlie Bennett71Deacon McGuire7336873.66 1.6
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Sy Sutcliffe74Deacon White71Charlie Ganzel72Deacon McGuire7336873.66 1.6
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Charlie Ganzel72Deacon White71Dan Brouthers74Deacon McGuire7336873.66 1.6
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Charlie Ganzel72Deacon White71Sy Sutcliffe74Deacon McGuire7336873.66 1.6
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Sy Sutcliffe74Deacon White71Dan Brouthers74Charlie Bennett7136873.66 1.6
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Sy Sutcliffe74Deacon White71Dan Brouthers74Jake Wells7136873.66 1.6
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Sy Sutcliffe74Deacon White71Charlie Bennett71Deacon McGuire7336773.46 1.4
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Ed Beatin69Charlie Ganzel72Dan Brouthers74Sy Sutcliffe7436773.46 1.4
Philadelphia PhilliesNL1896Ed Delahanty73Sam Mertes72Mike Grady71Dan Brouthers74Jack Boyle7636673.26 1.2
Washington SenatorsNL1895Jack Crooks70Parson Nicholson78Bill Hassamaer72Andy Boswell73Deacon McGuire7336673.26 1.2
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Ed Beatin69Charlie Ganzel72Dan Brouthers74Deacon McGuire7336673.26 1.2
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Ed Beatin69Deacon White71Dan Brouthers74Sy Sutcliffe7436673.26 1.2
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Ed Beatin69Charlie Ganzel72Sy Sutcliffe74Deacon McGuire7336673.26 1.2
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Sy Sutcliffe74Deacon White71Charlie Bennett71Charlie Ganzel7236673.26 1.2
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Charlie Ganzel72Deacon White71Sy Sutcliffe74Jake Wells7136673.26 1.2
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Charlie Ganzel72Deacon White71Dan Brouthers74Jake Wells7136673.26 1.2
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Sy Sutcliffe74Deacon White71Charlie Ganzel72Charlie Bennett7136673.26 1.2
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Charlie Ganzel72Deacon White71Dan Brouthers74Charlie Bennett7136673.26 1.2
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Charlie Ganzel72Deacon White71Charlie Bennett71Sy Sutcliffe7436673.26 1.2
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Sy Sutcliffe74Deacon White71Charlie Ganzel72Jake Wells7136673.26 1.2
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Sy Sutcliffe74Charlie Ganzel72Charlie Bennett71Jake Wells7136673.26 1.2
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Jack Rowe68Charlie Ganzel72Dan Brouthers74Sy Sutcliffe7436673.26 1.2
Detroit WolverinesNL1888Parson Nicholson78Charlie Ganzel72Deacon White71Sy Sutcliffe74Charlie Bennett7136673.26 1.2

Ok, if you've made it this far, hopefully I have some payoff for you. I ran the numbers for all teams to find the average height of each team's starting lineup. I adjusted the numbers for the major-league average for the given year since players have been growing gradually over the last 150 years. (Note that I included just those teams for which we have demographic for at least 5 starters.)

First, here are the shortest teams based on the average height for all starting position players (no adjustment for era):

YrTmLgWLPOSPCT Avg Ht Ft In
1872Troy HaymakersNA15105.600 67.0 5 7.0
1876St. Louis Brown StockingsNL45192.703 67.0 5 7.0
1880Buffalo BisonsNL24587.293 67.0 5 7.0
1874Philadelphia AthleticsNA33223.600 67.3 5 7.3
1887Cleveland BluesAA39928.298 67.3 5 7.3
1887Cleveland BluesAA39928.298 67.3 5 7.3
1875St. Louis Brown StockingsNA39294.574 67.4 5 7.4
1884Baltimore MonumentalsUA58474.552 67.4 5 7.4
1890St. Louis BrownsAA78583.574 67.4 5 7.4
1875Philadelphia AthleticsNA53202.726 67.6 5 7.6
1901Detroit TigersAL74613.548 67.6 5 7.6
1871Washington OlympicsNA15154.500 67.6 5 7.6
1874Chicago White StockingsNA28315.475 67.6 5 7.6
1877St. Louis Brown StockingsNL28324.467 67.6 5 7.6
1882Philadelphia AthleticsAA41342.547 67.6 5 7.6
1884St. Louis BrownsAA67404.626 67.6 5 7.6
1886Washington NationalsNL28928.233 67.6 5 7.6
1877St. Louis Brown StockingsNL28324.467 67.6 5 7.6
1884New York MetropolitansAA75321.701 67.7 5 7.7
1884New York MetropolitansAA75321.701 67.7 5 7.7
1886Washington NationalsNL28928.233 67.7 5 7.7
1871Philadelphia AthleticsNA2171.750 67.7 5 7.7

Here are the tallest:

YrTmLgWLPOSPCT Avg Ht Ft In
2005Arizona DiamondbacksNL77852.475 75.3 6 3.3
2002Tampa Bay Devil RaysAL551065.342 74.7 6 2.7
1968Washington SenatorsAL659610.404 74.4 6 2.4
1953Chicago CubsNL65897.422 74.4 6 2.4
1995Los Angeles DodgersNL78661.542 74.4 6 2.4
1996Toronto Blue JaysAL74884.457 74.2 6 2.2
1967Washington SenatorsAL76856.472 74.1 6 2.1
1976Cleveland IndiansAL81784.509 74.1 6 2.1
1995Toronto Blue JaysAL56885.389 74.1 6 2.1
1993Toronto Blue JaysAL95671.586 74.1 6 2.1
2004New York YankeesAL101611.623 74.1 6 2.1
1987Baltimore OriolesAL67956.414 74.1 6 2.1
2003Tampa Bay Devil RaysAL63995.389 74.1 6 2.1
2003St. Louis CardinalsNL85773.525 74.1 6 2.1
2000Cleveland IndiansAL90722.556 74.1 6 2.1
1977San Diego PadresNL69935.426 74.0 6 2.0
1969Washington SenatorsAL86764.531 74.0 6 2.0
1978San Francisco GiantsNL89733.549 74.0 6 2.0
2002Florida MarlinsNL79834.488 74.0 6 2.0
2002Cincinnati RedsNL78843.481 74.0 6 2.0
1986Oakland AthleticsAL76864.469 74.0 6 2.0
1989Chicago White SoxAL69927.429 74.0 6 2.0
1984Baltimore OriolesAL85775.525 74.0 6 2.0
2000Anaheim AngelsAL82803.506 74.0 6 2.0

Now, here are the shortest adjusted for era:

YrTmLgWLPOSPCT Avg Ht Ft In Adj Ht
1890St. Louis BrownsAA78583.574 67.4 5 7.4 0.964
1880Buffalo BisonsNL24587.293 67.0 5 7.0 0.965
1915Pittsburgh RebelsFL86673.562 68.3 5 8.3 0.966
1887Cleveland BluesAA39928.298 67.3 5 7.3 0.968
1901Detroit TigersAL74613.548 67.6 5 7.6 0.968
1876St. Louis Brown StockingsNL45192.703 67.0 5 7.0 0.968
1922Cincinnati RedsNL86682.558 68.4 5 8.4 0.970
1915Pittsburgh RebelsFL86673.562 68.6 5 8.6 0.971
1958Washington SenatorsAL61938.396 70.3 5 10.3 0.971
1892Washington SenatorsNL589310.384 68.0 5 8.0 0.971
1968Philadelphia PhilliesNL76867.469 70.4 5 10.4 0.971
1884Baltimore MonumentalsUA58474.552 67.4 5 7.4 0.971
1901Boston BeaneatersNL69695.500 67.8 5 7.8 0.972
1920Pittsburgh PiratesNL79754.513 68.4 5 8.4 0.972
1981San Diego PadresNL41696.373 70.8 5 10.8 0.973
1947Brooklyn DodgersNL94601.610 69.9 5 9.9 0.973
1914Pittsburgh RebelsFL64867.427 68.5 5 8.5 0.973
1977Seattle MarinersAL64986.395 70.6 5 10.6 0.973
1939Pittsburgh PiratesNL68856.444 69.7 5 9.7 0.973
1886Washington NationalsNL28928.233 67.6 5 7.6 0.973
1921Pittsburgh PiratesNL90632.588 68.4 5 8.4 0.973
1971Kansas City RoyalsAL85762.528 70.4 5 10.4 0.974
1977Seattle MarinersAL64986.395 70.7 5 10.7 0.974
1903Washington SenatorsAL43948.314 68.2 5 8.2 0.974
1939Boston BeesNL63887.417 69.7 5 9.7 0.974
1964Cleveland IndiansAL79837.488 70.8 5 10.8 0.974
1884St. Louis BrownsAA67404.626 67.6 5 7.6 0.974
1886Washington NationalsNL28928.233 67.7 5 7.7 0.974

Here are the tallest adjusted by era:

YrTmLgWLPOSPCT Avg Ht Ft In Adj Ht
1905Washington SenatorsAL64877.424 73.4 6 1.4 1.047
1906Washington SenatorsAL55957.367 73.0 6 1.0 1.040
1953Chicago CubsNL65897.422 74.4 6 2.4 1.033
1921New York YankeesAL98551.641 72.5 6 0.5 1.032
2005Arizona DiamondbacksNL77852.475 75.3 6 3.3 1.031
1968Washington SenatorsAL659610.404 74.4 6 2.4 1.027
1908Pittsburgh PiratesNL98562.636 72.2 6 0.2 1.026
1907Cincinnati RedsNL66876.431 72.2 6 0.2 1.026
1890Syracuse StarsAA55727.433 71.7 5 11.7 1.026
1891Philadelphia PhilliesNL68694.496 71.6 5 11.6 1.026
2002Tampa Bay Devil RaysAL551065.342 74.7 6 2.7 1.025
1928Brooklyn RobinsNL77766.503 72.8 6 0.8 1.025
1933Philadelphia AthleticsAL79723.523 73.0 6 1.0 1.024
1883Cincinnati Red StockingsAA61373.622 71.2 5 11.2 1.024
1887Detroit WolverinesNL79451.637 71.2 5 11.2 1.023
1888Detroit WolverinesNL68635.519 71.2 5 11.2 1.023
1967Washington SenatorsAL76856.472 74.1 6 2.1 1.023
1951Chicago CubsNL62928.403 73.6 6 1.6 1.023
1886Detroit WolverinesNL87362.707 71.0 5 11.0 1.022
1976Cleveland IndiansAL81784.509 74.1 6 2.1 1.022
1917St. Louis CardinalsNL82703.539 72.2 6 0.2 1.022
1932Cincinnati RedsNL60948.390 72.8 6 0.8 1.022
1896Philadelphia PhilliesNL62688.477 71.3 5 11.3 1.022
1956Pittsburgh PiratesNL66887.429 73.8 6 1.8 1.022
1955Chicago CubsNL72816.471 73.7 6 1.7 1.022
1971Washington SenatorsAL63965.396 73.9 6 1.9 1.021
1911Cincinnati RedsNL70836.458 71.9 5 11.9 1.021
1995Los Angeles DodgersNL78661.542 74.4 6 2.4 1.021
1895Philadelphia PhilliesNL78533.595 71.2 5 11.2 1.021
1884New York GothamsNL62504.554 70.8 5 10.8 1.020

Finally, I wanted to see if height had any connection to winning. I took the winning percentage and position in the standings for each team against the adjusted height and average height. And…drum roll, please…I got a big fat goose egg. The adjusted height had absolutely nothing to do with team winning percentage (coefficient 0.0005). Neither did position (0.0084). Using the average height for the team's starting position players, there was no relationship to winning percentage (0.0074) or position (-0.1775). These no relationship whatsoever.

So what does it all mean? Talent wins. It doesn't matter if a team's short or tall. If they're good, they win. I guess that should be self evident, but I was surprised to find that bigger teams didn't dominate in some way especially in the steroid era. And before you say that the juice doesn't make players taller just bigger, consider that I ran similar correlations for weight and found that there was ever-so-slightly more of a relationship, but still, no strong correlation. George Mitchell, take that and stick it in your report.

Comments
2006-04-05 22:11:30
1.   Ravenscar
Mike - I do think your posts rule, and I loved this one. I sent it to a 6'4" friend of mine and told him to imagine an infield where everyone was as freakishly tall as him.

But I am a little bit lost - how or why do you adjust height for era?

2006-04-05 22:12:08
2.   Ravenscar
Mike - I do think your posts rule, and I loved this one. I sent it to a 6'4" friend of mine and told him to imagine an infield where everyone was as freakishly tall as him.

But I am a little bit lost - how or why do you adjust height for era?

2006-04-05 22:20:03
3.   Mike Carminati
I took the average for all regular position players in the majors for the given year and divided the team's average by the major-league average. Regular players are those that played the most games at a given position for a given team (I split up OF to the RF, CF, and LF components.)

So why did I do it? I suppose "because it was there" doesn't really apply. How 'bout, to normalize for era.

Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.