Baseball Toaster Mike's Baseball Rants
Help
This is my site with my opinions, but I hope that, like Irish Spring, you like it, too.
Frozen Toast
Search
Google Search
Web
Toaster
Mike's Baseball Rants
Archives

2009
01 

2008
10  09  07 
06  05  04  03 

2007
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2006
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2005
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2004
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2003
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2002
12  11  10  09  08  07 
Links to MBBR
Debut Ante
2005-09-05 22:39
by Mike Carminati
Had I been less resolved to work, I would perhaps had made an effort to begin immediately...[I]t was better not to choose a night at which I was not well-disposed for a debut to which the following days proved, alas, no more propitious.
—Marcel Proust

When Hoyt Wilhem hit a home run in his first major-league at-bat just about three months shy of his thirtieth birthday, it must have been one of those Roy Hobbs-types moments. Wilhelm went on to hit zero home runs over the rest of his career (431 at-bats), but went on to set the major-league appearance record (1070 games), which has since been broken, and to record 21 major-league seasons, finishing his Hall-of-Fame career with the Dodgers 16 days before his fiftieth birthday.

Of all the Hall of Famers, who earned their paques as a simple major-league player, Wilhelm had the latest debut. There were Hall-of-Fame players, like Satchell Paige, who debuted two days after his 42nd birthday, whose major-league careers were delayed due to baseball's color line.

But of the 514 players through 2004 who debuted at age 30 or older, none have earned a spot in Cooperstown based solely on what he did on the field as a major-league player. Wilhelm is the only one of 341 major-leaguers who debuted at age 29 to make it into the Hall.

Cliff's questions to my previous post made me wonder how much debut age affected one's chances of getting into the Hall. Are players who debut in their teens that much better players so that larger numbers of them have entered the hallowed halls? How about those who debut in their twenties? Is there a difference between debuting at age 22 as opposed 25 or 27 as far as one's likelihood of getting into the Hall?

Well, I ran the numbers and here's what I found:

Debut Age#Players#HoFers%HoFers
N/A2860.00%
1420.00%
1520.00%
16190.00%
176534.62%
18232146.03%
19507285.52%
201011414.06%
211688392.31%
222188281.28%
232377190.80%
24236160.25%
251844110.60%
26133820.15%
2784010.12%
2859320.34%
2934110.29%
302070.00%
311160.00%
32800.00%
33510.00%
34200.00%
35100.00%
36110.00%
3760.00%
3830.00%
3940.00%
4040.00%
4120.00%
Total162081951.20%

To make it even clearer, I grouped the data by ranges:

Debut Age#Players#HoFers%HoFers
N/A2860.00%
14-19827455.44%
20-2248871082.21%
23-267920380.48%
27-30198140.20%
31-3527700.00%
36-413000.00%

The numbers show that by far the best group to belong to is the one with players who debuted in their teens. The next highest range is the 20-to-22-year-old debut group, in which Hall likelihood is about a two-fifths of the teen group. Other than those two groups, it's virtually impossible to get into the Hall (0.46% likelihood overall).

That made me wonder what this predicts about today's players. Given the breakdown of debut age for the 2004 group of players, here is the expectation, based on the odds in the past, of the players one day reaching the Hall:

Debut Age#PlayersExp HoFers% HoFers
18100.00%
191317.69%
205123.92%
2115131.99%
2220631.46%
2323920.84%
2422710.44%
2517010.59%
268700.00%
274200.00%
283100.00%
291300.00%
30900.00%
31200.00%
32300.00%
34100.00%
35100.00%
Total1247131.04%
Per Team 41.57 0.43 1.04%

Thirteen major-leaguers, less than half a player per team, that's the number expected to become Hall of Famers, none of whom debuted past age 25.

Where have all the Hoyt Wilhelm's gone?

Comments
2005-09-06 13:01:46
1.   Cliff Corcoran
Good stuff, Mike. This confirms what I believed to be true (though I didn't realize the trend was stronger all the way back to age 18!). But as we started in a discussion of King Felix, could you separate hitters and pitchers to see if, as I suspect there might be, there is some difference in the treds for the two groups.
2005-09-06 13:04:45
2.   Cliff Corcoran
Also, who are the six HOFers who debuted after age 25?
2005-09-07 05:36:18
3.   Mike Carminati
Name MinOfAge
Hoyt Wilhelm 29
Joe McGinnity 28
Jackie Robinson 28
Earl Averill 27
Roy Campanella 26
Mordecai Brown 26
2005-09-09 07:16:10
4.   Cliff Corcoran
Wow, so it's really just four, as Jackie and Campy were delayed by the color line.

Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.