Baseball Toaster Mike's Baseball Rants
Help
This is my site with my opinions, but I hope that, like Irish Spring, you like it, too.
Frozen Toast
Search
Google Search
Web
Toaster
Mike's Baseball Rants
Archives

2009
01 

2008
10  09  07 
06  05  04  03 

2007
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2006
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2005
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2004
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2003
12  11  10  09  08  07 
06  05  04  03  02  01 

2002
12  11  10  09  08  07 
Links to MBBR
No Flower Blooms For A Thousand Days
2005-06-02 09:39
by Mike Carminati
—Ancient Chinese proverb, huh?
A thousand moral paintings I can show
That shall demonstrate these quick blows of Fortune's
More pregnantly than words.

—William "Author" Shakespeare

The creation of a thousand forests is in one acorn, and Egypt, Greece, Rome, Gaul, Britain, America, lie folded in the first man.
—Ralph Waldo Emerson

As the Yankees prepare to fend off a sweep at the hands of the Buddy Bell-inspired Royals tonight, Jorge Posada will become just the 42nd catcher in baseball history to catch one thousand games with the same team. Number 41 was the Phils' Mike Lieberthal, who accomplished the feat Tuesday.

There are now three active catchers (Dan Wilson is the other) who have caught 1000 games for their current team. Three other catchers (Jason Kendall, Javy Lopez, and Ivan Rodriguez) have accomplished the feat for a previous team. Here's the complete list (including Posada):

CatcherTeamGFirst YrLast Yr
Jorge PosadaNew York Yankees99919952005
Mike LieberthalPhiladelphia Phillies100119942005
Dan WilsonSeattle Mariners123619942005
Jason KendallPittsburgh Pirates120519962004
Javy LopezAtlanta Braves110619922003
Ivan RodriguezTexas Rangers142619912002
Terry SteinbachOakland Athletics105019861996
Carlton FiskChicago White Sox123619811993
Rick DempseyBaltimore Orioles123019761992
Mike SciosciaLos Angeles Dodgers139519801992
Gary CarterMontreal Expos134219741992
Jim SundbergTexas Rangers149519741989
Ernie WhittToronto Blue Jays115919771989
Lance ParrishDetroit Tigers103919771986
Steve YeagerLos Angeles Dodgers118119721985
Johnny BenchCincinnati Reds174219671983
Bob BoonePhiladelphia Phillies109519721981
Ted SimmonsSt. Louis Cardinals143919681980
Thurman MunsonNew York Yankees127819691979
Manny SanguillenPittsburgh Pirates103719671979
Jerry GroteNew York Mets117619661977
Bill FreehanDetroit Tigers158119611976
Elston HowardNew York Yankees102919551967
Johnny RoseboroLos Angeles Dodgers119919581967
Sherm LollarChicago White Sox124119521963
Del CrandallMilwaukee Braves116719531963
Yogi BerraNew York Yankees169719461963
Del RiceSt. Louis Cardinals101819451960
Roy CampanellaBrooklyn Dodgers118319481957
Jim HeganCleveland Indians149119411957
Bill DickeyNew York Yankees170819281946
Ernie LombardiCincinnati Reds105319321941
Gabby HartnettChicago Cubs175919221940
Mickey CochranePhiladelphia Athletics114819251933
Cy PerkinsPhiladelphia Athletics109519151930
Ray SchalkChicago White Sox172219121928
Hank SevereidSt. Louis Browns109019151925
Oscar StanageDetroit Tigers107319091925
Steve O'NeillCleveland Indians110019151923
George GibsonPittsburgh Pirates115519051916
Billy SullivanChicago White Sox103319011914
Red DooinPhiladelphia Phillies112419021914

Now, here are the players with the most games caught for one team:

CatcherTeamGFirst YrLast Yr
Gabby HartnettChicago Cubs175919221940
Johnny BenchCincinnati Reds174219671983
Ray SchalkChicago White Sox172219121928
Bill DickeyNew York Yankees170819281946
Yogi BerraNew York Yankees169719461963
Bill FreehanDetroit Tigers158119611976
Jim SundbergTexas Rangers149519741989
Jim HeganCleveland Indians149119411957
Ted SimmonsSt. Louis Cardinals143919681980
Ivan RodriguezTexas Rangers142619912002

The Yankees had two catchers for about 35 years, and Texas had two catchers for essentially three decades—that's most of the team's history.

Given that there are six active catchers who have accomplished the feat, is this a new trend? Should we expect a slew of other catchers to join Lieberthal and Posada?

The short answer is no. Other than a couple of others, the seniority for backstops drops dramatically. Here are the active leaders for games caught with their current team:

CatcherTeamGFirst YrLast Yr
Dan WilsonSeattle Mariners123619942005
Mike LieberthalPhiladelphia Phillies100119942005
Jorge PosadaNew York Yankees99919952005
Jason VaritekBoston Red Sox83119972005
Brad AusmusHouston Astros81719972005
Mike PiazzaNew York Mets76919982005
Bengie MolinaAnaheim/LA Angels60319982005
Jason LaRueCincinnati Reds54619992005
Toby HallTampa Bay Devil Rays42320002005
Brian SchneiderMontreal Expos/Washington Nationals39420002005
Eddie PerezAtlanta Braves35719952005
Brandon IngeDetroit Tigers31620012005
Greg MyersToronto Blue Jays31619872005

Inge no longer catches. Myers is on his last legs at 39. Other than Varitek, who seems to be a lock, I'm not sure any are good bets. Offensively, Ausmus is a drag on the lineup. Piazza is aging, often injured, slumping, and one management decision away from no longer catching. The rest are too far away to predict.

So Posada may not be the last to catch a thousand games for one team, but he may be the last to do it with two days of someone else. Not that anyone in the ballpark will be thinking about it.

Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.